指南与共识泌尿系结石

泌尿系结石药物与手术治疗临床指南的定性综述:共识与争议

Qualitative Review of Clinical Guidelines for Medical and Surgical Management of Urolithiasis: Consensus and Controversy 2020.
指南 / 共识 · J Urol · 2020-12-07

该综述比较了全球5部高被引泌尿系结石指南(AUA 2019药物与2016手术、CUA 2016、EAU 2020、NICE 2019、UAA 2019),通过主题表格对比分析共识与分歧。结果显示结石药物治疗共识度高,输尿管结石手术共识包括α受体阻滞剂药物排石、非复杂输尿管镜不预置支架及输尿管镜或冲击波碎石一线治疗;肾结石治疗在AUA、EAU、NICE和UAA间共识高,CUA无肾结石指南;CUA和EAU对冲击波碎石患者选择有具体推荐。

要点

  • 结石药物治疗在各指南间共识度高。
  • 输尿管结石手术共识包括α受体阻滞剂药物排石、非复杂输尿管镜不预置支架及输尿管镜或冲击波碎石一线治疗。
  • CUA和EAU对冲击波碎石患者选择(结石密度、皮石距离等)有具体推荐,而AUA和NICE无。

核心结论

  • 最新AUA、CUA、EAU、NICE和UAA指南在结石药物和手术治疗上共识广泛,仅少数领域存在冲突。
  • 随访影像策略、结石监测、输尿管镜中输尿管通道鞘使用及微型经皮肾镜取石术指导等低证据领域是未来高级别临床研究的机会。

研究设计与样本

  • 定性综述,比较5部高被引指南:AUA 2019药物与2016手术、CUA 2016、EAU 2020、NICE 2019、UAA 2019。
  • 通过创建按主题关联指南陈述的表格进行对比分析,以确定共识与分歧。

主要发现

  • 药物治疗结石共识度高。
  • 输尿管结石手术治疗共识包括使用α受体阻滞剂药物排石、非复杂输尿管镜不预置支架及输尿管镜或冲击波碎石作为一线治疗。
  • 肾结石治疗在AUA、EAU、NICE和UAA指南间共识高;CUA无肾结石管理指南。
  • CUA和EAU对冲击波碎石患者选择有具体推荐,包括结石密度、皮石距离、治疗频率、声耦合及碎石后药物排石治疗;AUA和NICE无此类推荐。

临床怎么用

  • 临床可依据共识度高的推荐进行结石药物和手术治疗决策。
  • 对于冲击波碎石患者选择,可参考CUA和EAU关于结石密度、皮石距离等具体推荐。
  • 在低证据领域(如随访影像策略、输尿管通道鞘使用、微型经皮肾镜取石术)应关注新兴研究证据。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Many major guidelines across the globe address the medical and surgical management of urolithiasis. We elected to compare and contrast the recommendations among the 5 most highly cited guidelines on stone disease to offer insights on where evidence has created a consensus and where there remains ongoing controversy and hence a need for the pursuit of studies that will provide a higher level of evidence. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We reviewed the American Urological Association 2019 medical and 2016 surgical guidelines, the 2016 Canadian Urological Association guidelines, the 2020 European Association of Urology guidelines, the 2019 National Institute for Health and Care Excellence and the 2019 Urological Association of Asia guidelines. Tables correlating guideline statements by topic were created, and a comparative analysis was conducted to ascertain consensus and discordance. RESULTS: Comparative analysis of recommendations from the American Urological Association guidelines to the Canadian Urological Association, European Association of Urology, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidelines and Urological Association of Asia revealed a high consensus surrounding the medical management of stones. In terms of the surgical management of stones, there is high consensus regarding the treatment of ureteral stones including medical expulsive therapy using alpha blockers, not prestenting for uncomplicated ureteroscopy and employment of either ureteroscopy or shockwave lithotripsy as first line treatment. There is high consensus among the American Urological Association, European Association of Urology, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence and Urological Association of Asia guidelines regarding renal stone treatment. The Canadian Urological Association does not have guidelines on the management of renal stones. Unlike the American Urological Association and National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, the Canadian Urological Association and European Association of Urology make specific recommendations regarding selection of patients for shockwave lithotripsy procedures, including stone density, skin-to-stone distance, treatment rate, acoustic coupling and postshockwave lithotripsy use of medical expulsive therapy. CONCLUSIONS: There are many areas of consensus and only minor areas of conflict among the most up-to-date American Urological Association, Canadian Urological Association, European Association of Urology, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence and Urological Association of Asia guidelines on the medical and surgical management of stone disease. Conflicts among guidelines and areas of low evidence, such as followup imaging strategies and stone surveillance, the use of a ureteral access sheath in ureteroscopy and guidance on the use of miniaturized percutaneous nephrolithotomy, are opportunities for novel, impactful high grade clinical studies.

来源:J Urol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jiang P, Xie L, Arada R, et al. Qualitative Review of Clinical Guidelines for Medical and Surgical Management of Urolithiasis: Consensus and Controversy 2020. J Urol. 2020. PMID: 33284671. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000001478

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。