CLOCK II 腹腔镜肾部分切除术随机试验的方案偏离:真实世界分析
离夹组 32.5% 转为夹闭,夹闭组 56.9% 因术者主观决策未夹闭。转换与肿瘤大小/复杂度相关,术中转换对术后病程似乎无害,避免动脉夹闭在早期功能结局上有优势。
要点
- 离夹组 32.5% 转为夹闭,夹闭组 56.9% 转为离夹。
- 转为夹闭者肿瘤更大(4 vs 3 cm,p=0.002),手术时间更长,术后第1天 eGFR 变化更大。
- 按方案完成夹闭者术后第1天 eGFR 下降>25% 的比例更高(29.4% vs 10.3%,p=0.009)。
核心结论
- 夹闭策略的转换取决于肿瘤大小和复杂度,术中转换对术后病程似乎无害。
- 避免动脉夹闭在早期功能结局方面存在优势。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验的真实世界分析,纳入 6 家机构连续接受腹腔镜肾部分切除术的候选者。
- 共 123 例随机至夹闭组,126 例随机至离夹组。
主要发现
- 离夹组 41 例(32.5%)转为夹闭,夹闭组 70 例(56.9%)未夹闭肾动脉。
- 转为夹闭者肿瘤更大(4 vs 3 cm,p=0.002),手术时间更长,术后第1天 eGFR 变化更大。
- 转为离夹者肿瘤更小(3.7 vs 3 cm,p=0.002),R.E.N.A.L. 评分更低(6 vs 5,p=0.038),手术时间更短。
- 按方案完成夹闭者术后第1天 eGFR 下降>25% 的比例更高(29.4% vs 10.3%,p=0.009)。
- 肿瘤增大和完全内生型生长预测转为夹闭,而阻止转为离夹;BMI>28 预测转为离夹。
临床怎么用
- 术前应根据肿瘤大小和复杂度预判夹闭策略转换的可能性。
- 术中根据实际情况转换夹闭策略安全可行,不必过度顾虑术后病程。
- 在条件允许时优先考虑避免动脉夹闭以保护早期肾功能。
局限性
- 转换至夹闭或离夹取决于术者主观术中决策,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 本研究为随机试验的事后分析,转换组间比较非随机化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We assess factors/additional morbidities related to the conversion of clamping approach during off-clamp vs on-clamp laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in the setting of a randomized study. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Consecutive candidates for laparoscopic partial nephrectomy from 6 institutions were randomized to on-clamp or off-clamp surgery. The present study analyzed 1) off-clamp arm patients, comparing the procedures finalized per protocol without artery clamping (off-clamp) to those needing renal artery clamping (shift-on-clamp) and 2) on-clamp arm patients, comparing the procedures finalized with artery clamping (on-clamp) to those completed without clamping (shift-off-clamp). RESULTS: A total of 123 patients were randomized to on-clamp and 126 to off-clamp surgery. Of the off-clamp patients 41 (32.5%) converted to on-clamp. Of the on-clamp patients 70 (56.9%) completed surgery without clamping the renal artery due to subjective intraoperative decision of the surgeon. Tumor size was greater in shift-on-clamp vs off-clamp cases (4 vs 3, p=0.002). Conversely, tumor size (3.7 vs 3 cm, p=0.002) and R.E.N.A.L. nephrometry score (6 vs 5, p=0.038) were lower in shift-off-clamp cases. Shift-on-clamp cases had longer operative times and greater changes in estimated glomerular filtration rate on postoperative day 1. Shift-off-clamp cases had shorter operative times. A higher proportion of patients who completed on-clamp surgery per protocol had a greater than 25% drop in estimated glomerular filtration rate on postoperative day 1 (29.4%) compared to smaller changes (10.3%, p=0.009) in estimated glomerular filtration rate. Increasing tumor size and complete endophytic growth pattern predicted shift-on-clamp while preventing shift-off-clamp. Body mass index above 28 predicted shift-off-clamp. CONCLUSIONS: The likelihood of shift-on/off-clamp relies on tumor size/complexity. The intraoperative need to convert the planned strategy seemed harmless on postoperative course. An advantage in terms of early functional outcomes does exist when avoiding artery clamping.
引用
- Bove P, Bertolo R, Sandri M, et al. Deviation from the Protocol of a Randomized Clinical Trial Comparing On-Clamp versus Off-Clamp Laparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy (CLOCK II Laparoscopic Study): A Real-Life Analysis. J Urol. 2020. PMID: 33035141. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000001417
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。