新型分离手势分类系统用于表征机器人肾门分离技术
本研究将机器人辅助肾部分切除术中的肾门分离动作分解为基本手势,由6位专家共识建立分类系统,并比较专家与新手的手术模式。共回顾40例视频(专家16例、新手24例),识别9819个手术动作,其中分离动作5667个,归纳为9种分离手势、3大类。专家在5/9种手势上效率更高,且在肾静脉分离时更多使用剥离/推压、更少使用热切,在肾动脉分离时更多使用血管蒂化。
要点
- 肾门分离可分解为9种离散手势,归为钝性、锐性和组合三类。
- 专家在5/9种分离手势上效率高于新手(p≤0.033)。
- 专家分离肾静脉时更多用剥离/推压、更少用热切(p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 新型分离手势分类系统能区分专家与新手在机器人肾门分离中的技术差异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性视频分析,共40例机器人辅助肾部分切除术的肾门准备视频,其中专家(≥100例机器人手术)6人16例,新手(<100例)13人24例。
- 手术动作由人工审阅识别,分离手势经6位专家共识分类。
主要发现
- 共识别9819个手术动作,包括5667个分离动作和4152个支持动作。
- 识别出9种离散分离手势,分为单钝性分离(撑开、剥离/推压、钩)、单锐性分离(冷切、热切和烧灼分离)及组合手势(血管蒂化、双手撑开、凝固后切)。
- 专家在9种分离手势中的5种上效率高于新手(p≤0.033)。
- 分离肾静脉时,专家更多使用剥离/推压、更少使用热切(p<0.001)。
- 分离肾动脉时,专家更多使用血管蒂化(p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 该分类系统可用于机器人手术技能教学与评估,帮助识别专家与新手分离模式的差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Deconstruction of robotic surgical gestures into semantic vocabulary yields an effective tool for surgical education. In this study we disassembled tissue dissection into basic gestures, created a classification system, and showed its ability to distinguish between experts and novices. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Videos of renal hilum preparation during robotic assisted partial nephrectomies were manually reviewed to identify all discrete surgical movements. Identified dissection movements were classified into distinct gestures based on the consensus of 6 expert surgeons. This classification system was then employed to compare expert and novice dissection patterns during the renal hilum preparation. RESULTS: A total of 40 robotic renal hilum preparation videos were reviewed, representing 16 from 6 expert surgeons (100 or more robotic cases) and 24 from 13 novice surgeons (fewer than 100 robotic cases). Overall 9,819 surgical movements were identified, including 5,667 dissection movements and 4,152 supporting movements. Nine distinct dissection gestures were identified and classified into the 3 categories of single blunt dissection (spread, peel/push, hook), single sharp dissection (cold cut, hot cut and burn dissect) and combination gestures (pedicalize, 2-hand spread, and coagulate then cut). Experts completed 5 of 9 dissection gestures more efficiently than novices (p ≤0.033). In consideration of specific anatomical locations, experts used more peel/push and less hot cut while dissecting the renal vein (p <0.001), and used more pedicalize while dissecting the renal artery (p <0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Using this novel dissection gesture classification system, key differences in dissection patterns can be found between experts/novices. This comprehensive classification of dissection gestures may be broadly applied to streamline surgical education.
引用
- Ma R, Vanstrum EB, Nguyen JH, et al. A Novel Dissection Gesture Classification to Characterize Robotic Dissection Technique for Renal Hilar Dissection. J Urol. 2020. PMID: 33095096. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000001328
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。