文献速递小儿泌尿与泌尿修复

人工智能数字模式识别与经验丰富小儿泌尿外科医生在尿道下裂识别与分类中的对比

Digital Pattern Recognition for the Identification and Classification of Hypospadias Using Artificial Intelligence vs Experienced Pediatric Urologist.
PubMed 文献 · Urology · 2020-09-26

该研究利用1169张标准化尿道下裂图像训练TensorFlow图像识别模型,将图像分为远端型或近端型,并在29张测试图像上与小儿泌尿外科专家分类对比。使用627张图像训练后准确率为60%,使用1169张图像后准确率提升至90%。专家间评分一致性Fleiss Kappa为k=0.86,专家内为0.74,模型模拟了专家间几乎完美的一致性。

要点

  • 基于1169张图像训练的模型对尿道下裂远端/近端分类准确率达90%。
  • 专家间一致性k=0.86,专家内一致性k=0.74,模型模拟专家间一致性。
  • 未来需标准化该技术并探索其临床适用性。

核心结论

  • 图像识别模型模拟了专家对远端/近端尿道下裂的分类,专家间一致性k=0.86,专家内k=0.74。
  • 未来需标准化这些技术的使用及其临床适用性。

研究设计与样本

  • 使用含1169张匿名图像的尿道下裂图像数据库,其中远端837张、近端332张。
  • 图像标准化为阴茎腹侧包括龟头、阴茎体和阴囊,分为远端或近端,上传至TensorFlow训练。
  • 训练数据输出至TensorBoard评估损失函数,模型在随机选取的29张测试图像上运行。
  • 同一组29张图像分发给小儿泌尿外科专家临床医生,使用Fleiss Kappa进行评分者间和评分者内分析。

主要发现

  • 使用627张图像训练后,检测准确率为60%。
  • 使用1169张图像训练后,准确率提升至90%。
  • 专家间分析k=0.86,专家内分析k=0.74。
  • 图像识别模型模拟了专家间几乎完美的一致性。

临床怎么用

  • 该模型可模拟专家对尿道下裂远端/近端分类,未来或有助于标准化分类并减少评估者间主观性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To improve hypospadias classification system, we hereby, show the use of machine learning/image recognition to increase objectivity of hypospadias recognition and classification. Hypospadias anatomical variables such as meatal location, quality of urethral plate, glans size, and ventral curvature have been identified as predictors for postoperative outcomes but there is still significant subjectivity between evaluators. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A hypospadias image database with 1169 anonymized images (837 distal and 332 proximal) was used. Images were standardized (ventral aspect of the penis including the glans, shaft, and scrotum) and classified into distal or proximal and uploaded for training with TensorFlow. Data from the training were outputted to TensorBoard, to assess for the loss function. The model was then run on a set of 29 "Test" images randomly selected. Same set of images were distributed among expert clinicians in pediatric urology. Inter- and intrarater analyses were performed using Fleiss Kappa statistical analysis using the same 29 images shown to the algorithm. RESULTS: After training with 627 images, detection accuracy was 60%. With1169 images, accuracy increased to 90%. Inter-rater analysis among expert pediatric urologists was k= 0.86 and intrarater 0.74. Image recognition model emulates the almost perfect inter-rater agreement between experts. CONCLUSION: Our model emulates expert human classification of patients with distal/proximal hypospadias. Future applicability will be on standardizing the use of these technologies and their clinical applicability. The ability of using variables different than only anatomical will feed deep learning algorithms and possibly better assessments and predictions for surgical outcomes.

来源:Urology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fernandez N, Lorenzo AJ, Rickard M, et al. Digital Pattern Recognition for the Identification and Classification of Hypospadias Using Artificial Intelligence vs Experienced Pediatric Urologist. Urology. 2020. PMID: 32991907. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2020.09.019

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。