泌尿外科高影响力期刊作者性别差异:五年回顾
该研究回顾了2014年1月至2019年6月五本高影响力泌尿外科期刊的8653篇多作者论文,记录第一作者和最后作者的性别。结果显示女性第一作者占26.3%,与女性住院医师比例相当;女性最后作者占14.5%,高于执业女性泌尿外科医生比例。女性最后作者时第一作者为女性的比值比为2.34。
要点
- 女性第一作者比例26.3%,与女性住院医师比例25%相当。
- 女性最后作者比例14.5%,高于执业女性泌尿外科医生比例9%。
- 女性最后作者时第一作者为女性的OR为2.34(95%CI 2.06-2.65)。
核心结论
- 女性第一作者和最后作者的比例显著高于泌尿外科女性执业比例,可能反映亚专科选择和导师机会差异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性文献分析,检索2014年1月至2019年6月五本高影响力泌尿外科期刊的原创论文,共纳入8653篇多作者论文。
主要发现
- 527篇(6.1%)论文第一和最后作者均为女性,而5640篇(65.3%)均为男性。
- 女性最后作者时第一作者为女性的OR为2.34(95%CI 2.06-2.65)。
- 多数女性第一和最后作者论文发表于亚专科期刊及采用双盲同行评审的期刊。
临床怎么用
- 提示女性在泌尿外科研究中的参与度高于执业比例,关注亚专科选择和导师机会可能促进性别多样性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe the proportions of peer-reviewed manuscripts authored by women in 5 high-impact, widely available urology journals, and to compare these to the proportion of women in urology. About 9% of attending urologists and 25% of urology residents are women. We hypothesized that women comprised fewer than 25% of first authors and fewer than 10% of last/senior authors. METHODS: We searched peer-reviewed original manuscripts in the Journal of Urology, Journal of Pediatric Urology, Neurourology and Urodynamics, Urology, and Urologic Oncology from January 2014 to June 2019. First and last author gender identity was recorded. Observed and expected proportions and temporal trends were compared, with findings considered statistically significant at P < .05. RESULTS: Of 8653 multiple-author papers, 2275 (26.3%) had women as first authors, paralleling the current proportion of women in training (P = .98). Women were senior/last authors in 1255 (14.5%) papers; this was higher than the current proportion of female urologists in practice (P < .0001) for all journals but NAU (P = .59). Only 527 (6.1%) of multiple-author papers had both female first and last authors whereas 5640 (65.3%) of papers had both male first and last authors. The first author was more likely female when the senior author was female (OR = 2.34, 95% CI: 2.06-2.65); most female-first and -last authored manuscripts were published in subspecialty journals and those utilizing double-blind peer review. CONCLUSION: The proportion of female first- and senior-authored manuscripts is significantly higher than the proportion of women in urology, and may reflect differential subspecialty choices and mentorship opportunities for women.
引用
- Whitley JA, Holt SK, Nelson D, et al. Gender Differences in Authorship in Urology: a Five-year Review of Publications in Five High-impact Journals. Urology. 2020. PMID: 32966819. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2020.07.080
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。