改良自体筋膜经闭孔吊带术与标准经闭孔吊带术的前瞻性比较
前瞻性纳入117例患者(a-TOT组36例,TOT组81例),比较改良自体筋膜经闭孔吊带术(a-TOT)与标准经闭孔吊带术(TOT)的疗效与并发症。平均随访21.5±1.1个月,两组客观治愈率(97.3% vs 97.6%,P=.998)和主观治愈率(97.3% vs 92.5%,P=.664)相似,总体并发症率相似;a-TOT组手术时间更长,但ICIQ-FLUTS总分及生活质量评分改善更优。
要点
- a-TOT与TOT的客观和主观治愈率及总体并发症率相似。
- a-TOT组手术时间显著长于TOT组(P=.001)。
- a-TOT组在排尿功能障碍及新发充盈期症状方面改善更优。
核心结论
- a-TOT与TOT的客观治愈率、主观治愈率及总体并发症率相似,且a-TOT在术后排尿功能障碍和新发充盈期症状方面结果更好。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究纳入117例患者,其中a-TOT组36例、TOT组81例,平均随访21.5±1.1个月。
主要发现
- a-TOT组与TOT组手术时间比较P=.001,a-TOT组更长。
- 术后8小时和24小时视觉模拟评分(VAS)及总体并发症率两组相似。
- Clavien 3级并发症仅见于TOT组(3.7%)。
- 依据咳嗽压力试验(CST)的客观治愈率a-TOT组97.3%、TOT组97.6%(P=.998)。
- 依据患者整体改善印象量表(PGI-I)的主观治愈率a-TOT组97.3%、TOT组92.5%(P=.664),TOT组1例因失败需再手术。
关键数值与推荐
- ICIQ-FLUTS总分及总生活质量评分改善a-TOT组优于TOT组(P=.028和P=.032)。
- ICIQ-FLUTS充盈期和排尿期子评分及生活质量子评分改善a-TOT组优于TOT组(P=.043、P=.048、P=.034和P=.039)。
临床怎么用
- a-TOT可作为TOT的替代术式,在保持相似治愈率与并发症率的同时可能改善术后排尿功能及充盈期症状。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare modified autologous transobturator-tape (a-TOT) and transobtrator-tape (TOT) surgeries in terms of effectivity and complications. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Prospectively 117 patients (a-TOT:36,TOT:81) were enrolled in this study. A-TOT was performed with autologous fascia elongated with nonabsorbable sutures and TOT was performed with standard technique. Preoperative data regarding operative time, complications and postoperative visual analog scores (VAS) were noted. Patients were assessed 12 months after surgery. Objective cure was evaluated with cough stress test (CST) and necessity of reoperation due to failure while subjective cure was evaluated with Patient Global Impression of Improvements scale(PGI-I) and the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire-Female Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms(ICIQ-FLUTS) questionnaire. RESULTS: The mean follow-up time was 21.5 ± 1.1 months. Preoperative demographic characteristics were similar. The mean operation time was longer in a-TOT group(P = .001).VAS at postoperative 8. and 24. hours and overall complication rates were similar for the groups. Clavien grade-3 complications occurred only in TOT group (3.7%). Objective cure rates according to CST were 97.3% and 97.6% (P = .998) and the subjective cure rates according to PGI-I were 97.3% and 92.5% (P = .664) for a-TOT and TOT groups, respectively. One patient in TOT group needed reoperation. The a-TOT group gained better improvements in total score and total QoL score of ICIQ-FLUTS (P = .028 and P = .032, respectively) as well as subscore and QoL subscore of filling and voiding sections of ICIQ-FLUTS (P = .043, P = .048,P = .034, and P = .039, respectively). CONCLUSION: The a-TOT technique has similar objective and subjective cure rates and overall complication rates furthermore better results in postoperative voiding dysfunction and de-novo filling phase symptoms when compared to TOT.
引用
- Cubuk A, Yanaral F, Sahan A, et al. Modified Autologous Transobturator Tape Surgery - A Prospective Comparison With Transobturator Tape Surgery. Urology. 2020. PMID: 32979380. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2020.09.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。