瑞典LAPPRO试验:术者异质性显著影响根治性前列腺切除术后的功能与肿瘤学结局
LAPPRO为前瞻性非随机对照试验,纳入瑞典14中心68名术者实施的4003例局限期前列腺癌根治术。在至少完成20例手术的25名术者中,尿失禁(P=0.001)、勃起功能障碍(P<0.001)和复发(P<0.001)均存在显著异质性;术者手术量可解释部分异质性,且校正术者因素会改变RALP与RRP比较的显著性。
要点
- 术者间尿失禁、勃起功能障碍和复发率存在显著异质性
- 术者手术量可解释部分异质性,对复发率影响最大
- 比较RALP与RRP时必须校正术者因素,否则结论可能改变
核心结论
- 术者间功能和肿瘤学结局存在较大异质性,并显著影响RALP与RRP的比较结果。
- 部分异质性可由术者手术量差异解释,减少异质性有必要。
研究设计与样本
- LAPPRO为前瞻性、对照、非随机试验,在瑞典14个中心由68名术者实施。
- 2008至2011年共纳入4003例局限期前列腺癌男性,比较RALP与RRP。
- 终点为术后24个月尿失禁、勃起功能障碍和复发,采用逻辑回归评估术者异质性。
主要发现
- 在完成至少20例手术的25名术者中,尿失禁(P=0.001)、勃起功能障碍(P<0.001)和复发率(P<0.001)存在显著异质性。
- 仅分析自述经验至少250例根治性前列腺切除术的12名有经验术者,显著异质性仍存在。
- 在全部68名术者中,术者手术量差异解释尿失禁异质性的42%(P=0.003)、勃起功能障碍的11%(P=0.03)、复发的19%(P=0.01)。
- 比较RALP与RRP时考虑术者手术量对结果有显著影响,对功能结局影响最大,额外校正术者既往经验可改变技术间差异的统计学显著性。
- 术者年手术量对复发率的影响最大。
临床怎么用
- 解读根治性前列腺切除术式比较研究时,应充分考虑术者异质性并校正术者手术量及经验。
- 减少术者间结局差异有助于改善功能和肿瘤学结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate how surgeon heterogeneity - the variation in outcomes between individual surgeons - influences functional and oncological outcomes after robot-assisted laparoscopic prostatectomy (RALP) and retropubic radical prostatectomy (RRP), and to assess whether surgeon heterogeneity affects the comparison between RALP and RRP. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Laparoscopic Prostatectomy Robot Open (LAPPRO) is a prospective, controlled, non-randomized trial performed at 14 Swedish centres with 68 operating surgeons. A total of 4003 men with localized prostate cancer were enrolled between 2008 and 2011. The endpoints were urinary incontinence, erectile dysfunction (ED) and recurrence at 24 months after surgery. Logistic regression models were built to evaluate surgeon heterogeneity and, secondarily, surgeon-specific factors were added to the models to investigate their influence on heterogeneity and the comparison between RALP and RRP. RESULTS: Among surgeons who performed at least 20 surgeries during the study period (n=25), we observed statistically significant heterogeneity for incontinence (P = 0.001), ED (P < 0.001) and rate of recurrent disease (P < 0.001). The significant heterogeneity remained when analysing only experienced surgeons with a stated experience of at least 250 radical prostatectomies (n=12). Among all participating surgeons (n=68), differences in surgeon volume explained 42% of the observed heterogeneity for incontinence (P = 0.003), 11% for ED (P = 0.03) and 19% for recurrence (P = 0.01). Taking surgeon volume into account when comparing RALP and RRP had a significant impact on the results. The effect was greatest for functional outcomes, and the additional adjustments for the surgeons' previous experience changed whether the difference between techniques was statistically significant or not. The surgeons' annual volume had the greatest effect on the recurrence rate. CONCLUSIONS: There was a large degree of heterogeneity among surgeons regarding both functional and oncological outcomes and this had a significant impact on the results when comparing RALP and RRP. Some of the observed heterogeneity was explained by differences in surgeon volume. Efforts to decrease heterogeneity are warranted and variation among surgeons must be accounted for when conducting comparative analyses between surgical techniques.
引用
- Nyberg M, Sjoberg DD, Carlsson SV, et al. Surgeon heterogeneity significantly affects functional and oncological outcomes after radical prostatectomy in the Swedish LAPPRO trial. BJU Int. 2020. PMID: 32916021. doi:10.1111/bju.15238
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。