评估YouTube上膀胱过度活动症患者教育材料质量:基于PEMAT的初步研究
研究于2019年9月10日检索YouTube上「膀胱过度活动症」前25条结果,并用PEMAT评估其可理解性与可操作性;另对比3条Urology Care Foundation(UCF)视频。结果发现前25条视频的可理解性平均74%±16%、可操作性平均57%±39%,而UCF视频分别为93%和100%,但未出现在前25条搜索结果中。
要点
- YouTube上OAB患者教育视频的可理解性与可操作性差异显著。
- UCF的OAB视频PEMAT评分远高于普通搜索结果,但搜索排名靠后。
- AUA/UCF与SUFU可加强在YouTube等平台的患者 outreach。
核心结论
- YouTube上OAB患者教育材料的可理解性与可操作性质量参差不齐。
- UCF的OAB视频PEMAT评分显著更高,但未出现在前25条搜索结果中。
研究设计与样本
- 于2019年9月10日检索YouTube上「overactive bladder」前25条结果,并对比3条UCF的OAB教育视频。
- 使用AHRQ的PEMAT音频视觉材料工具评分,分为可理解性与可操作性两个领域,各满分100%。
主要发现
- 前25条视频平均时长9.5分钟(范围0.9–34分钟),平均观看量151,382次(范围127–2,032,441次)。
- 前25条视频PEMAT可理解性平均74%±16%(范围41%–100%),可操作性平均57%±39%(范围0%–100%)。
- 3条UCF视频平均观看量5840次,平均时长3分钟,PEMAT可理解性93%、可操作性100%,且均由泌尿外科医生出镜。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参考PEMAT评分筛选或推荐可理解性与可操作性较高的OAB患者教育视频。
- 专业学会可考虑在YouTube等平台优化患者教育内容的可及性与搜索排名。
局限性
- 本研究为初步研究,仅纳入前25条搜索结果和3条UCF视频,样本量有限。
- 检索时间为2019年9月10日,结果可能随时间变化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the characteristics and quality of patient education content for overactive bladder (OAB) on YouTube. METHODS: We searched YouTube on September 10, 2019 and reviewed the top 25 search results for "overactive bladder." For comparison, we reviewed 3 Urology Care Foundation (UCF) OAB education videos on YouTube. Videos were scored using the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality's Patient Education Materials Assessment Tool (PEMAT) for Audiovisual materials, which is subdivided into understandability and actionability domains, each with a maximum score of 100%. RESULTS: The mean length was 9.5 (0.9-34) minutes and the mean number of views was 151,382 (127-2,032,441). Of the top 25 search results, the mean PEMAT understandability score was 74% ± 16% (range 41%-100%). The mean PEMAT actionability score was 57% ± 39% (range 0%-100%). Seventy-two percent of the reviewed videos featured a physician. In comparison, the 3 UCF videos had an average of 5840 views, 3 minutes length, and PEMAT understandability and actionability scores of 93% and 100%. All UCF OAB videos featured urologists. CONCLUSION: The quality of OAB patient education materials on YouTube varies significantly in understandability and actionability. Although the UCF videos scored much higher on the PEMAT than our reviewed videos, they did not appear within the top 25 search results for OAB. There is great opportunity for the American Urological Association (AUA)/UCF and Society of Urodynamics, Female Pelvic Medicine & Urogenital Reconstruction (SUFU) to increase its outreach to patients on platforms like YouTube.
引用
- Ji L, Sebesta EM, Stumbar SE, et al. Evaluating the Quality of Overactive Bladder Patient Education Material on YouTube: A Pilot Study Using the Patient Education Materials Assessment Tool. Urology. 2020. PMID: 32827536. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2020.08.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。