COVID-19疫情期间泌尿外科择期手术恢复优先评分系统的批判性评估
该研究评估了基于问卷(MeNTS)、专家共识和个体外科医生三种方法对204例因COVID-19推迟的择期泌尿外科病例的优先排序效果。结果显示MeNTS评分未能有意义地分层病例(不同优先级别间p=0.129),专家共识与个体外科医生评分仅轻微一致(Kappa=0.131),三种方法排序结果显著不同。
要点
- MeNTS问卷评分未能有效区分泌尿外科病例的紧急程度。
- 专家共识与个体外科医生优先评分间一致性差(Kappa=0.131)。
- 未来灾难规划需综合考虑各优先排序系统的优缺点。
核心结论
- 基于问卷、专家共识和个体外科医生的优先排序方法导致显著不同的病例优先级。
- 基于问卷的MeNTS评分未能有意义地分层泌尿外科病例。
- 专家共识与个体外科医生优先评分经常不一致。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性评估2020年3月9日至5月22日期间因COVID-19大流行推迟的204例择期泌尿外科病例。
- 使用三种优先排序方法:基于问卷的MeNTS instrument、基于已发表泌尿外科推荐的共识/专家意见、以及本部门开发管理的个体外科医生评分。
- 较低评分代表更高紧急程度。
主要发现
- 204例病例中,MeNTS评分中位数为50(IQR 44, 55)。
- 共识/专家意见优先评分平均为2.6±0.6,个体外科医生优先评分平均为2.2±0.8。
- 个体外科医生优先1、2、3级病例的MeNTS评分中位数分别为52(46.5, 57.5)、50(44.5, 54.5)、48(43.5, 54),p=0.129。
- 共识/专家意见优先1、2、3级病例的MeNTS评分中位数分别为55(51.5, 57)、47.5(42, 56)、49(44, 54),p=0.002。
- 共识/专家意见与个体外科医生优先评分之间一致性为无到轻微(Kappa 0.131,p=0.002)。
临床怎么用
- 在恢复择期手术时,不应单独依赖MeNTS问卷评分进行泌尿外科病例分层。
- 专家共识和个体外科医生评分可能提供不同视角,需结合使用并认识其不一致性。
- 未来灾难规划中应评估并整合各优先排序系统的优势与不足。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Resumption of elective urology cases postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic requires a systematic approach to case prioritization, which may be based on detailed cross-specialty questionnaires, specialty specific published expert opinion or by individual (operating) surgeon review. We evaluated whether each of these systems effectively stratifies cases and for agreement between approaches in order to inform departmental policy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We evaluated triage of elective cases postponed within our department due to the COVID-19 pandemic (March 9, 2020 to May 22, 2020) using questionnaire based surgical prioritization (American College of Surgeons Medically Necessary, Time Sensitive Procedures [MeNTS] instrument), consensus/expert opinion based surgical prioritization (based on published urological recommendations) and individual surgeon based surgical prioritization scoring (developed and managed within our department). Lower scores represented greater urgency. MeNTS scores were compared across consensus/expert opinion based surgical prioritization and individual surgeon based surgical prioritization scores. RESULTS: A total of 204 cases were evaluated. Median MeNTS score was 50 (IQR 44, 55), and mean consensus/expert opinion based surgical prioritization and individual surgeon based surgical prioritization scores were 2.6±0.6 and 2.2±0.8, respectively. Median MeNTS scores were 52 (46.5, 57.5), 50 (44.5, 54.5) and 48 (43.5, 54) for individual surgeon based surgical prioritization priority 1, 2 and 3 cases (p=0.129), and 55 (51.5, 57), 47.5 (42, 56) and 49 (44, 54) for consensus/expert opinion based surgical prioritization priority scores 1, 2, and 3 (p=0.002). There was none to slight agreement between consensus/expert opinion based surgical prioritization and individual surgeon based surgical prioritization scores (Kappa 0.131, p=0.002). CONCLUSIONS: Questionnaire based, expert opinion based and individual surgeon based approaches to case prioritization result in significantly different case prioritization. Questionnaire based surgical prioritization did not meaningfully stratify urological cases, and consensus/expert opinion based surgical prioritization and individual surgeon based surgical prioritization frequently disagreed. The strengths and weaknesses of each of these systems should be considered in future disaster planning scenarios.
引用
- Cohn JA, Ghiraldi EM, Uzzo RG, et al. A Critical Appraisal of the American College of Surgeons Medically Necessary, Time Sensitive Procedures (MeNTS) Scoring System, Urology Consensus Recommendations and Individual Surgeon Case Prioritization for Resumption of Elective Urological Surgery During the COVID-19 Pandemic. J Urol. 2020. PMID: 32716742. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000001315
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。