远程膀胱镜与传统膀胱镜的清晰度、熟练度及诊断能力盲法比较:一项初步研究
本研究由外部评审者对6例远程膀胱镜和传统膀胱镜视频进行盲法回顾比较,共36次评估。远程膀胱镜在检查彻底性上达92%,传统为100%,异常识别信心相当;6个视频中4个对下一步措施的评审者间一致率为100%。结论认为远程膀胱镜检查完整性好、异常识别能力相当,可能扩大膀胱癌监测的可及性。
要点
- 远程膀胱镜由高级执业提供者操作、泌尿科医生远程实时判读,检查彻底性达92%。
- 远程传输视频清晰度低于现场视频,但异常识别信心与诊断一致性高。
- 该模型可能扩大膀胱癌监测的可及性,尤其适用于医疗资源不足地区。
核心结论
- 远程膀胱镜模型具有极佳的检查完整性、相当的异常识别能力,并获得外部评审对后续措施的验证。
- 该初步研究提示远程膀胱镜可能扩大膀胱癌监测的可及性。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心前瞻性收集视频数据,由外部评审者进行盲法回顾性比较。
- 每位患者均接受由受训高级执业提供者操作的远程膀胱镜和由现场泌尿科医生操作的传统膀胱镜。
- 共回顾6例远程膀胱镜诊疗,总计36次评估;每个视频由独立评审者评估并评分两次。
主要发现
- 视频清晰度(以传输速度和图像分辨率定义)现场视频优于传输的远程膀胱镜视频。
- 检查彻底性的操作者熟练度评分:远程膀胱镜为92%,传统膀胱镜为100%。
- 识别异常的信心相当。
- 6个视频中有4个对下一步措施的评审者间一致率为100%,表明诊断一致性高。
- 执行膀胱镜的提供者和地点对诊断或采取行动的能力无统计学影响。
关键数值与推荐
- 检查彻底性熟练度:远程膀胱镜92%,传统膀胱镜100%。
- 6个视频中4个对下一步措施的评审者间一致率为100%。
临床怎么用
- 在医疗资源不足地区,可由受训高级执业提供者操作膀胱镜、泌尿科医生远程实时判读,以扩大膀胱癌监测可及性。
- 远程传输视频清晰度低于现场视频,判读时需注意图像质量可能的影响。
局限性
- 本研究为初步研究,样本量小(6例远程膀胱镜诊疗,36次评估)。
- 远程传输视频的清晰度低于现场视频。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: In order to expand the availability of cystoscopy to underserved areas we have proposed using advanced practice providers to perform cystoscopy with real-time interpretation by the urologist on a telemedicine platform, termed "tele-cystoscopy." The purpose of this study is to have blinded external reviewers retrospectively compare multisite, prospectively collected video data from tele-cystoscopy with the video of traditional cystoscopy in terms of video clarity, practitioner proficiency and diagnostic capability. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Each patient underwent tele-cystoscopy by a trained advanced practice provider and traditional cystoscopy with an onsite urologist. Prospectively collected tele-cystoscopy transmitted video, tele-cystoscopy onsite video and traditional cystoscopy video were de-identified and blinded to external reviewers. Each video was evaluated and rated twice by independent reviewers and diagnostic agreement was quantified. RESULTS: Six tele-cystoscopy encounters were reviewed for a total of 36 assessments. Video clarity, defined by speed of transmission and image resolution, was better for onsite compared to transmitted tele-cystoscopy. Practitioner proficiency for thoroughness of inspection was rated at 92% for tele-cystoscopy and 100% for traditional cystoscopy. Confidence in identification of an abnormality was equivalent. Four of 6 videos had 100% agreement between reviewers for next action taken, indicating high diagnostic agreement. Additionally, provider performing cystoscopy and location did not statistically influence the ability to make a diagnosis or action taken. CONCLUSIONS: This model has excellent completeness of examination, equivalent ability to identify abnormalities and external validation of action taken. This pilot study demonstrates that tele-cystoscopy may expand access to bladder cancer surveillance.
引用
- Lobo JM, Horton B, Jones RA, et al. Blinded Comparison of Clarity, Proficiency and Diagnostic Capability of Tele-Cystoscopy Compared to Traditional Cystoscopy: A Pilot Study. J Urol. 2020. PMID: 32330408. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000001092
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。