Aquablation 术后输血率:不同止血方法的比较
该研究汇总 2014 至 2019 年初 801 例接受 Aquablation 治疗的患者数据,评估不同止血方法对输血率的影响。结果显示,使用导管牵拉装置(CTD)进行强力牵拉且不电凝时,大前列腺的输血风险显著增加;而采用标准牵拉方法并在必要时行膀胱颈电凝,各前列腺体积的输血风险降低至 1.9%。
要点
- Aquablation 术后总体输血率为 3.9%(31/801)。
- 前列腺体积增大时,CTD 强力牵拉无电凝的输血风险从 0.8% 升至 7.8%。
- 标准牵拉联合选择性膀胱颈电凝可将各体积前列腺输血风险降至 1.9%。
核心结论
- 使用 CTD 强力牵拉且不电凝时,小前列腺的输血率与标准方法相当,但大前列腺的输血风险显著增加。
- 采用标准牵拉方法并在必要时行膀胱颈电凝,可将各前列腺体积的输血风险降至 1.9%。
研究设计与样本
- 汇总 2014 年至 2019 年初多国临床试验数据及法国、德国、西班牙的早期商业手术数据,共纳入 801 例接受 Aquablation 治疗的患者。
- 平均(标准差,范围)前列腺体积为 67(33,20-280)mL。
主要发现
- 共报告 31 例输血(3.9%)。
- 输血风险的最大影响因素是前列腺大小和牵拉方法。
- 使用 CTD 强力牵拉且不电凝时,前列腺体积 20-280 mL 的输血风险范围为 0.8%-7.8%。
- 采用标准牵拉(导尿管固定于腿部、纱布结系至尿道口或无牵拉)并在必要时行膀胱颈电凝时,前列腺体积 20-280 mL 的输血风险范围为 1.4%-2.5%。
关键数值与推荐
- 总体输血率为 3.9%(31/801)。
- CTD 强力牵拉无电凝组输血风险 0.8%-7.8%(前列腺体积 20-280 mL)。
- 标准牵拉联合选择性膀胱颈电凝组输血风险 1.4%-2.5%(前列腺体积 20-280 mL),各体积总体风险降至 1.9%。
临床怎么用
- 对于接受 Aquablation 的患者,尤其是大前列腺患者,应避免使用 CTD 强力牵拉且不电凝的止血方式。
- 推荐采用标准牵拉方法(导尿管固定于腿部、纱布结系至尿道口或无牵拉),并在必要时行膀胱颈电凝以降低输血风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine if athermal methods are as effective in preventing blood transfusions as the use of cautery across various prostate volumes following prostate tissue resection for benign prostatic hyperplasia using Aquablation. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The current commercial AQUABEAM robot that performs Aquablation therapy was first used in 2014. Since then numerous clinical studies have been conducted in various countries; Australia, Canada, Germany, India, Lebanon, Spain, New Zealand, United Kingdom, and the United States. All of the clinical trial data since 2014 were pooled with the early commercial procedures from France, Germany, and Spain to determine the effectiveness of haemostatic techniques in reducing the transfusion rate in patients after Aquablation. RESULTS: In all, 801 patients were treated with Aquablation therapy from 2014 to early 2019. The mean (SD, range) prostate volume was 67 (33, 20-280) mL and 31 (3.9%) transfusions were reported. The largest contributing factor to transfusion risk was prostate size and method of traction. There was an increasing risk of transfusions in larger prostates when robust traction using a catheter-tensioning device (CTD) without cautery was used, ranging from 0.8% to 7.8% in prostates ranging from 20 to 280 mL. However, when standard traction (taping the catheter to the leg, gauze knot synched up to the meatus, or no traction at all) was used and where the surgeon performed bladder neck cautery only when necessary, the risk of transfusion was 1.4-2.5% in prostates ranging from 20 to 280 mL. CONCLUSIONS: While the athermal subgroup with robust traction with a CTD had comparable transfusion rates for smaller prostates, the risk increased significantly as prostate volume increased. With standard traction methods and selective bladder neck cautery, the risk of transfusion was reduced to 1.9% across all prostate sizes.
引用
- Elterman D, Bach T, Rijo E, et al. Transfusion rates after 800 Aquablation procedures using various haemostasis methods. BJU Int. 2020. PMID: 31901210. doi:10.1111/bju.14990
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。