电话随访在女性泌尿外科中的可行性与可靠性:PHONE 前瞻性对照研究
该前瞻性对照研究纳入 420 例因压力性尿失禁(SUI)行中段尿道吊带术或前壁阴道壁脱垂(POP)行修补术的女性,比较电话随访与门诊随访的一致性。电话随访在无尿失禁主诉者中可行可靠,但可能将新发急迫性尿失禁误判为 SUI 复发;POP 无假体修补者电话随访有效,假体侵蚀仅门诊客观检查发现。
要点
- 电话随访在无尿失禁报告的女性中可行且可靠。
- 电话随访可能将新发急迫性尿失禁误判为 SUI 复发。
- 吊带/网片侵蚀仅能通过门诊客观检查发现。
核心结论
- 电话随访对无尿失禁主诉的女性可行可靠,但对报告失禁者可靠性下降。
- POP 无假体修补者电话随访有效,假体侵蚀需门诊客观检查。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性对照研究,纳入 420 例女性:A 组 215 例 SUI 行中段尿道吊带术,B 组 205 例 POP 行前壁阴道壁修补术。
- 1 年随访先电话清单与验证问卷,7–12 天后门诊复诊含问诊、问卷、客观检查及电话随访满意度评分。
主要发现
- SUI 复发率电话随访 19.1%、门诊随访 11.6%。
- 新发急迫性尿失禁发生率 7.5%。
- 吊带与网片侵蚀仅门诊客观检查发现,分别为 1.9% 与 4.4%。
- 问卷评分无差异,电话随访满意度高。
临床怎么用
- 对无尿失禁主诉的女性可采用电话随访替代部分门诊随访。
- 报告失禁者需门诊进一步评估以鉴别 SUI 复发与新发急迫性尿失禁。
- POP 假体修补术后需门诊客观检查排除侵蚀。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determinate the feasibility, reliability, and patient satisfaction of telephonic follow-up in women treated for stress urinary incontinence (SUI) or pelvic organ prolapse (POP): Patient-Home-Office-Novel-Evaluation (PHONE) study. METHODS: This is a prospective comparative study in women following surgery for SUI underwent middle urethral sling (MUS) (Group A), or symptomatic anterior vaginal wall (AVW) defect underwent AVW repair (fascial/mesh/biomesh) (Group B). The 1-year follow-up included a telephonic interview using a checklist and validated questionnaires followed by a standard outpatient clinic visit 7-12 days later including: an interview, validated questionnaires, objective examination, and score satisfaction with the telephone follow-up. RESULTS: We enrolled 420 pts: 215 for SUI in Group A, and 205 for POP in Group B. SUI recurrence was 19.1% and 11.6% at the telephone and office follow-up, respectively. De-novo urgency urinary incontinence rate was 7.5%. Telephone follow-up was able to detect POP recurrence and related symptoms. Tape and mesh extrusions were detected only at the objective evaluation: 1.9% and 4.4% respectively. No difference was found at the questionnaires. Satisfaction with the telephone follow-up was high. CONCLUSION: Due to the wrongly interpretation of de-novo urge urinary incontinence as a recurrence of SUI, a telephone interview may lose reliability in case of reported incontinence. Thus, telephone follow-up was feasible and reliable in women not reporting incontinence. In patients treated for POP the phone interview was a valid tool only in case of no-prosthetic surgery due to the absence of extrusion in these cases.
引用
- Balzarro M, Rubilotta E, Trabacchin N, et al. A Prospective Comparative Study of the Feasibility and Reliability of Telephone Follow-Up in Female Urology: The Patient Home Office Novel Evaluation (PHONE) Study. Urology. 2019. PMID: 31726182. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2019.10.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。