尿道下裂手术并发症发生率差异:US News与PHIS数据及文献比较
该研究利用PHIS数据库分析尿道下裂修复术后翻修率,发现US News采用的CPT代码组A在远端和近端修复中的并发症率分别为3.32%和12.29%,扩大代码列表后远端翻修率显著增加至6.37%,近端增至22.14%。结论认为US News质量指标不能准确反映尿道下裂手术并发症的本质。
要点
- US News代码组远端和近端并发症率分别为3.32%和12.29%。
- 扩大翻修代码列表后远端翻修率显著升至6.37%。
- 延长随访7年翻修率有上升趋势但无统计学意义。
核心结论
- 根据翻修定义不同,PHIS数据集中无医院达到US News定义的完美标准。
- US News质量指标不能准确反映尿道下裂手术并发症发生率。
研究设计与样本
- 基于PHIS数据库的回顾性分析,查询尿道下裂及翻修CPT代码。
- 定义3个CPT组:A组为US News代码,B组增加获得性尿道皮肤瘘代码,C组增加所有相关翻修代码。
- 评估随访时间延长至7年的翻修率变化。
主要发现
- A组远端修复平均并发症率为3.32%(范围0.48%-7.36%),近端为12.29%(范围3.48%-36.36%)。
- 远端修复中,B组翻修率4.26%(p<0.001)和C组6.37%(p<0.001)均显著高于A组。
- 近端修复中,B组12.53%与A组12.29%无显著差异(p=0.813),C组22.14%显著高于A组(p<0.001)。
- 所有3组中,远端和近端尿道下裂的中位翻修率随随访延长而增加,但趋势无统计学意义。
关键数值与推荐
- 远端尿道下裂修复并发症率文献报告为5%-10%,近端为12%-23%。
- US News代码组A远端并发症率3.32%,近端12.29%。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估尿道下裂手术质量时需注意翻修定义和随访时间对并发症率的影响。
- US News质量指标可能低估真实并发症率,不宜作为唯一评价标准。
局限性
- 随访时间延长至7年的翻修率上升趋势未达统计学显著性。
- 研究基于PHIS数据库,可能受代码记录准确性限制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Complication rates of 5% to 10% and 12% to 23% have been observed following distal and proximal hypospadias repair, respectively. However, these rates may be overreported. We hypothesized that data from the Pediatric Health Information System would corroborate the complication rates reported in the literature and refute the rates established by U.S. News & World Report as quality metrics. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The Pediatric Health Information System database was interrogated for hypospadias and revision CPT® codes. To evaluate the appropriateness of the U.S. News & World Report code list to identify revisions, 3 CPT groups were defined. Group A included codes sought by U.S. News & World Report, group B included group A plus codes for acquired urethrocutaneous fistula in males and group C included group B plus any revision codes associated with the index procedures. To evaluate the appropriateness of U.S. News & World Report followup interval, we assessed revision rates with ever increasing followup intervals out to 7 years. Yearly revision rates were summarized by median and quantile to correlate whether median revision rates changed significantly depending on whether increased followup or enhanced code lists were used. RESULTS: Average complication rates for group A were 3.32% (range 0.48% to 7.36%) and 12.29% (3.48% to 36.36%) for distal and proximal repairs, respectively. Revision rates increased significantly from group A (median 3.32%) by inclusion of a more expansive list of CPT codes associated with revision procedures (group B, 4.26%, p <0.001 and group C, 6.37%, p <0.001) in distal hypospadias. Among proximal hypospadias cases this difference was not significant when comparing group A (12.29%) to group B (12.53%, p=0.813), but was significant when comparing group A to group C (22.14%, p <0.001). Median revision rates for distal and proximal hypospadias increased with longer followup for all 3 groups, although the upward trend was not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Depending on how one defines hypospadias revision, no hospital within the Pediatric Health Information System data set meets the U.S. News & World Report definition of perfection, a finding that is supported by recent reports from some of the largest, most prolific and most highly regarded pediatric urology programs. We posit that the U.S. News & World Report quality metrics do not accurately reflect the nature of hypospadias surgery complication rates.
引用
- Pohl HG, Rana S, Sprague BM, et al. Discrepant Rates of Hypospadias Surgical Complications: A Comparison of U.S. News & World Report and Pediatric Health Information System® Data and Published Literature. J Urol. 2019. PMID: 31526260. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000000554
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。