成人及儿童膀胱结石的治疗:代表欧洲泌尿外科学会尿石症指南专家组的系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入25项研究共2340例患者,评估成人及儿童膀胱结石各种治疗方式的结石清除率与并发症。结果显示在可行情况下经尿道膀胱碎石术是成人及儿童膀胱结石的首选干预方式,冲击波碎石效果较差,内镜手术与开放手术疗效相当且恢复更快。
要点
- 经尿道膀胱碎石术在可行情况下是成人及儿童膀胱结石的首选干预方式。
- 冲击波碎石结石清除率低于经尿道膀胱碎石术(风险比0.88,p=0.03,低质量证据)。
- 经尿道与经皮膀胱碎石结石清除率无差异,但住院时间和手术时间更短。
核心结论
- 现有证据表明,在可行的情况下,经尿道膀胱碎石术是成人及儿童膀胱结石的首选干预方式。
- 需要进一步开展高质量研究。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,代表欧洲泌尿外科学会尿石症指南专家组开展,遵循欧洲泌尿外科学会指南办公室方法。
- 检索1970年至2019年数据库,纳入比较随机对照试验和非随机研究(每组至少10例患者),共评估2742篇摘要和59篇全文,最终纳入25项研究共2340例患者。
- 使用推荐分级的评估、制定与评价(GRADE)工具评估证据质量。
主要发现
- 成人中,一项随机对照试验发现冲击波碎石后结石清除率低于经尿道膀胱碎石术(风险比0.88,p=0.03;低质量证据)。
- 四项随机对照试验比较经尿道膀胱碎石术与经皮膀胱碎石术,Meta分析显示结石清除率无差异,但住院时间(平均差0.82天,p<0.00001)和手术时间(平均差9.83分钟,p<0.00001)有利于经尿道膀胱碎石术(中等质量证据)。
- 四项非随机研究比较开放膀胱切开取石术与经尿道膀胱碎石术或经皮膀胱碎石术,结石清除率无差异,住院时间和手术时间有利于内镜手术(极低质量证据)。
- 四项随机对照试验比较使用肾镜与膀胱镜行经尿道膀胱碎石术,Meta分析显示结石清除率无差异,手术时间有利于使用肾镜(平均差22.74分钟,p<0.00001;中等质量证据)。
- 儿童中,一项非随机研究显示冲击波碎石后结石清除率低于经尿道膀胱碎石术或开放膀胱切开取石术;两项非随机研究比较开放膀胱切开取石术与经尿道膀胱碎石术或经皮膀胱碎石术,结石清除率相似,导尿管留置时间和住院时间有利于内镜治疗;一项随机对照试验比较激光与气压弹道经尿道膀胱碎石术,结石清除率无差异;一项大型非随机研究比较开放膀胱切开取石术技术,发现选定病例中无管化开放膀胱切开取石术后住院时间更短;证据质量极低。
关键数值与推荐
- 成人冲击波碎石与经尿道膀胱碎石术比较:风险比0.88,p=0.03,低质量证据。
- 成人经尿道膀胱碎石术与经皮膀胱碎石术比较:结石清除率无差异;住院时间平均差0.82天,p<0.00001;手术时间平均差9.83分钟,p<0.00001;中等质量证据。
- 成人肾镜与膀胱镜行经尿道膀胱碎石术比较:结石清除率无差异;手术时间平均差22.74分钟,p<0.00001;中等质量证据。
临床怎么用
- 作者结论认为,在可行的情况下,经尿道膀胱碎石术是成人及儿童膀胱结石的首选干预方式。
- 作者指出需要进一步高质量研究。
- 患者摘要指出内镜手术与开放手术疗效相当,冲击波碎石效果似乎较差,内镜治疗导尿管留置时间和恢复时间更短,经尿道手术住院时间短于经皮手术。
局限性
- 需要进一步开展高质量研究。
- 尚不清楚结石大小是否影响结局。
- 需要进一步研究以明确微创治疗对较大结石和幼儿的疗效。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
CONTEXT: Bladder stones (BS) constitute 5% of urinary stones. Currently, there is no systematic review of their treatment. OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy (primary outcome: stone-free rate [SFR]) and morbidity of BS treatments. EVIDENCE ACQUISITION: This systematic review was conducted in accordance with the European Association of Urology Guidelines Office. Database searches (1970-2019) were screened, abstracted, and assessed for risk of bias for comparative randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and nonrandomised studies (NRSs) with ≥10 patients per group. Quality of evidence (QoE) was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) tool. EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS: A total of 2742 abstracts and 59 full-text articles were assessed, and 25 studies (2340 patients) were included. In adults, one RCT found a lower SFR following shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) than transurethral cystolithotripsy (TUCL; risk ratio 0.88, p=0.03; low QoE). Four RCTs compared TUCL versus percutaneous cystolithotripsy (PCCL): meta-analyses demonstrated no difference in SFR, but hospital stay (mean difference [MD] 0.82d, p<0.00001) and procedure duration (MD 9.83min, p<0.00001) favoured TUCL (moderate QoE). Four NRSs comparing open cystolithotomy (CL) versus TUCL or PCCL found no difference in SFR; hospital stay and procedure duration favoured endoscopic surgery (very low QoE). Four RCTs compared TUCL using a nephroscope versus a cystoscope: meta-analyses demonstrated no difference in SFR; procedure duration favoured the use of a nephroscope (MD 22.74min, p<0.00001; moderate QoE). In children, one NRS showed a lower SFR following SWL than TUCL or CL. Two NRSs comparing CL versus TUCL/PCCL found similar SFRs; catheterisation time and hospital stay favoured endoscopic treatments. One RCT comparing laser versus pneumatic TUCL found no difference in SFR. One large NRS comparing CL techniques found a shorter hospital stay after tubeless CL in selected cases; QoE was very low. CONCLUSIONS: Current available evidence indicates that TUCL is the intervention of choice for BSs in adults and children, where feasible. Further high-quality research on the topic is required. PATIENT SUMMARY: We examined the literature to determine the most effective and least harmful procedures for bladder stones in adults and children. The results suggest that endoscopic surgery is equally effective as open surgery. It is unclear whether stone size affects outcomes. Shock wave lithotripsy appears to be less effective. Endoscopic treatments appear to have shorter catheterisation time and convalescence compared with open surgery in adults and children. Transurethral surgery, where feasible, appears to have a shorter hospital stay than percutaneous surgery. Further research is required to clarify the efficacy of minimally invasive treatments for larger stones and in young children.
引用
- Donaldson JF, Ruhayel Y, Skolarikos A, et al. Treatment of Bladder Stones in Adults and Children: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis on Behalf of the European Association of Urology Urolithiasis Guideline Panel. Eur Urol. 2019. PMID: 31311676. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2019.06.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。