两种阴茎折叠术的患者满意度与长期结果比较:来自387例阴茎弯曲患者的经验教训
本回顾性研究纳入387例阴茎弯曲患者(先天性260例,Peyronie病127例),比较Lue 16点折叠术(202例)与改良Nesbit白膜浅表切除成形术(185例)的满意度和长期结果。16点折叠术手术时间更短(48.1±7.5分钟 vs 63±16.9分钟,P=.001),两组完全伸直率无差异(87.6% vs 89.7%,P=.514)。改良Nesbit组阴茎感觉丧失(P=.001)和新发勃起功能障碍(P=.016)发生率更高,而16点折叠术组缝线相关并发症更高(P=.001)。
要点
- 16点折叠术手术时间显著短于改良Nesbit成形术(48.1±7.5分钟 vs 63±16.9分钟,P=.001)。
- 两组完全阴茎伸直率无显著差异(87.6% vs 89.7%,P=.514)。
核心结论
- 两种手术技术总体成功率和满意度均很高,并发症率很低,但并发症类型在两种手术间有显著差异。
- 作者认为,应告知阴茎弯曲患者阴茎折叠术的结果,并根据患者偏好和术者经验选择手术方法。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入387例阴茎弯曲患者,其中先天性阴茎弯曲260例,Peyronie病127例。
- 202例接受Lue 16点白膜折叠术,185例接受改良Nesbit白膜浅表切除阴茎成形术。
- 比较两种技术的 surgical outcomes 和患者满意度。
主要发现
- 平均手术时间16点折叠术组为48.1±7.5分钟,显著短于改良Nesbit组的63±16.9分钟(P=.001)。
- 完全阴茎伸直率16点折叠术组为87.6%,改良Nesbit组为89.7%,两组无差异(P=.514)。
- 阴茎感觉丧失率(P=.001)和新发勃起功能障碍率(P=.016)在改良Nesbit组显著高于16点折叠术组。
- 缝线相关并发症率在16点折叠术组显著高于改良Nesbit组(P=.001)。
- 先天性阴茎弯曲患者术后阴茎长度损失比例和新发勃起功能障碍比例显著低于Peyronie病患者。
关键数值与推荐
- 完全阴茎伸直:16点折叠术组87.6% vs 改良Nesbit组89.7%(P=.514)。
- 平均手术时间:16点折叠术组48.1±7.5分钟 vs 改良Nesbit组63±16.9分钟(P=.001)。
- 阴茎感觉丧失率:改良Nesbit组高于16点折叠术组(P=.001)。
- 新发勃起功能障碍率:改良Nesbit组高于16点折叠术组(P=.016)。
- 缝线相关并发症率:16点折叠术组高于改良Nesbit组(P=.001)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,应告知阴茎弯曲患者阴茎折叠术的结果,并根据患者偏好和术者经验选择手术方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the patient's satisfaction and long-term results of 2 penile plication procedures in patients with penile curvature. METHODS: This retrospective study included 387 patients with congenital penile curvature (n = 260) and Peyronie's disease (n = 127) who underwent surgical correction of penile curvature with penile plication procedures. Of the patients, 202 underwent plication of tunica albuginea with the Lue's 16-dot technique, while 185 underwent highly superficial excision of tunica albuginea with the modified Nesbit corporoplasty. Surgical outcomes and patient's satisfaction were compared between the 2 techniques in all patients. RESULTS: The mean duration of surgery was significantly shorter in the 16-dot plication technique (48.1 ± 7.5 minutes), compared with the modified Nesbit corporoplasty (63 ± 16.9 minutes) (P = .001). Complete penile straightening was achieved in 87.6% of the patients who underwent 16-dot plication technique and in 89.7% of the patients who underwent modified Nesbit plication, revealing no difference (P = .514). The rates of penile sensory loss (P = .001) and de-novo erectile dysfunction (P = .016) were significantly higher in the modified Nesbit corporoplasty than in the 16-dot plication technique, but rate of suture related complications was significantly higher in the 16-dot plication technique than in the modified Nesbit corporoplasty (P = .001). The patients with congenital penile curvature had significantly less ratio of postoperative penile length loss and de-novo erectile dysfunction than Peyronie's disease patients. CONCLUSION: Overall, both surgical techniques have very high success and satisfaction rates with very low complication rates. However, the types of complications are significantly different between the 2 surgical procedures. Therefore, patients with penile curvature should be informed about outcomes of penile plication procedures, and surgical method should be preferred based on patient's preference and surgeon's experience.
引用
- Çayan S, Aşcı R, Efesoy O, et al. Comparison of Patient's Satisfaction and Long-term Results of 2 Penile Plication Techniques: Lessons Learned From 387 Patients With Penile Curvature. Urology. 2019. PMID: 30954611. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2019.02.039
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。