多机构手术结局研究组中尿道狭窄病因与尿道成形术式的趋势变化
该研究回顾了2010至2017年间10位术者完成的2098例前尿道成形术,分析尿道狭窄特征与术式随时间的变化。特发性/未知病因在所有研究年份均为最常见病因(63%)。球部尿道切除修复减少而替代修复增多,背侧移植物增加而腹侧减少,阴茎部尿道筋膜皮瓣减少而单期背侧修复增加,术者间及术者内对相似狭窄的手术处理存在差异。
要点
- 特发性/未知病因在所有研究年份均为最常见狭窄病因,占63%。
- 球部尿道切除修复减少31%,替代修复增加78%。
- 球部替代修复中背侧移植物增加95%,腹侧减少75%。
核心结论
- 前尿道成形术技术在缺乏有力临床数据或随机对照试验的情况下持续演变,本队列总体趋向于对大多数狭窄采用初始背侧入路。
- 注意到术者间及术者内对相似狭窄的手术处理存在差异,在缺乏明显手术均势的情况下,未来任何随机对照试验的可行性必须受到质疑。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析多机构前瞻性维护的尿道成形术数据库,纳入2010至2017年间10位术者完成的2098例前尿道成形术。
- 分析狭窄特征(病因、长度、解剖位置)并与研究期间尿道成形术式比较,使用卡方分析评估组内及按术者的线性趋势。
主要发现
- 球部狭窄平均长度2.8±1.8 cm,阴茎部3.6±2.6 cm,阴茎-球部8.7±5.0 cm,均保持稳定。
- 特发性/未知病因在所有研究年份均为最常见病因,占63%。
- 球部尿道:切除修复减少31%,替代修复增加78%。
- 球部替代修复中,背侧移植物增加95%,腹侧减少75%;球部切除修复中,不横断球部尿道者增加430%。
- 阴茎部尿道:筋膜皮瓣减少86%,单期背侧修复增加280%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To analyze contemporary urethroplasty trends and urethral stricture etiologies over a 7-year study period among urologists from a large multi-institutional surgical outcomes group. METHODS: Review of a multi-institutional, prospectively maintained urethroplasty database was performed on 2098 anterior urethroplasties done between 2010 and 2017 by 10 surgeons. Stricture characteristics, including etiology, length, and anatomic location were analyzed and compared to urethroplasty type over the study period using chi-squared analysis to assess for linear trends within the group and by surgeon. RESULTS: Average stricture lengths for bulbar (2.8 ± 1.8 cm), penile (3.6 ± 2.6 cm), and penile-bulbar strictures (8.7 ± 5.0) remained stable. The most common stricture etiology was idiopathic/unknown in all study years (63%). In the bulbar urethra, the group performed significantly (1) fewer excisional repairs (-31%) and more substitutional repairs (+78%); (2) of substitutional repairs, more grafts are being placed dorsally (+95%) vs ventrally (-75%) (3) of the bulbar excisional repairs, more are being performed without transection of the bulbar urethra (+430%); and in the penile urethra (4) the fasciocutaneous flap is in decline (-86%), while single-stage dorsal repairs are increasing (+280%). CONCLUSION: Anterior urethroplasty techniques continue to evolve in the absence of robust clinical data or randomized controlled trials, with a general movement in this cohort toward an initial dorsal approach for most strictures. Inter- and intrasurgeon variability in the surgical management of similar strictures was noted, and the feasibility of any future randomized controlled trials, without apparent surgical equipoise, must be questioned.
引用
- Cotter KJ, Hahn AE, Voelzke BB, et al. Trends in Urethral Stricture Disease Etiology and Urethroplasty Technique From a Multi-institutional Surgical Outcomes Research Group. Urology. 2019. PMID: 30880075. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2019.01.046
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。