父母对膀胱输尿管反流治疗的偏好:一项基于众包的最佳-最差量表研究
研究通过亚马逊 Mechanical Turk 在线社区对父母进行最佳-最差量表调查,采用多项式逻辑回归分析,评估父母对膀胱输尿管反流各治疗属性的偏好。结果显示,治疗效果(PSV=20.37)最重要,其次是未来尿路感染风险(PSV=14.85)和并发症发生率(PSV=14.55);社会成本、住院时间和美观最不重要。父母对开放与微创手术的美观结局无偏好差异(P=0.791),根据属性偏好权重,父母会选择开放手术的时间占74.9%。
要点
- 治疗效果是父母最看重的属性(PSV=20.37)。
- 未来尿路感染风险(PSV=14.85)和并发症发生率(PSV=14.55)次之。
- 社会成本(PSV=1.41)、住院时间(PSV=1.09)和美观(PSV=0.91)最不重要。
核心结论
- 高治疗效果是父母最重要且最偏好的属性,而成本和美观属于最不重要的属性。
- 研究结果有助于促进父母与医生关于膀胱输尿管反流治疗的共享决策。
研究设计与样本
- 通过亚马逊 Mechanical Turk 在线社区对父母进行众包调查,使用2种最佳-最差量表调查工具收集偏好数据。
- 属性及属性水平基于对反流文献的广泛回顾选定。
- 受访者完成对象案例最佳-最差量表练习以对反流治疗的一般方面进行优先排序,并完成多剖面案例最佳-最差量表以引出对反流治疗具体差异的偏好。
- 数据采用多项式逻辑回归分析。
- 对象案例和多剖面案例的最佳-最差量表分析分别纳入248名和228名受访者的数据。
主要发现
- 在优先排序反流治疗的一般方面时,治疗效果(PSV=20.37)、未来尿路感染风险(PSV=14.85)和并发症发生率(PSV=14.55)对父母最重要。
- 社会成本(PSV=1.41)、住院时间(PSV=1.09)和美观(PSV=0.91)最不重要。
- 父母对开放手术与微创手术的美观结局偏好无差异(P=0.791)。
- 结合属性偏好权重,本研究中父母选择开放手术的时间占74.9%。
临床怎么用
- 研究结果可用于促进父母与医生关于膀胱输尿管反流治疗的共享决策。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To quantitatively evaluate parental preferences for the various treatments for vesicoureteral reflux using crowd-sourced best-worst scaling, a novel technique in urologic preference estimation. METHODS: Preference data were collected from a community sample of parents via 2 best-worst scaling survey instruments published to Amazon's Mechanical Turk online community. Attributes and attribute levels were selected following extensive review of the reflux literature. Respondents completed an object case best-worst scaling exercise to prioritize general aspects of reflux treatments and multiprofile case best-worst scaling to elicit their preferences for the specific differences in reflux treatments. Data were analyzed using multinomial logistic regression. Results from the object-case provided probability scaled values (PSV) that reflected the order of importance of attributes. RESULTS: We analyzed data for 248 and 228 respondents for object and multiprofile case BWS, respectively. When prioritizing general aspects of reflux treatment, effectiveness (PSV = 20.37), risk of future urinary tract infection (PSV = 14.85), and complication rate (PSV = 14.55) were most important to parents. Societal cost (PSV = 1.41), length of hospitalization (PSV = 1.09), and cosmesis (PSV = 0.91) were least important. Parents perceived no difference in preference for the cosmetic outcome of open vs minimally invasive surgery (P = .791). Bundling attribute preference weights, parents in our study would choose open surgery 74.9% of the time. CONCLUSION: High treatment effectiveness was the most important and preferred attribute to parents. Alternatively, cost and cosmesis were among the least important. Our findings serve to inform shared parent-physician decision-making for vesicoureteral reflux.
引用
- Dionise ZR, Gonzalez JM, Garcia-Roig ML, et al. Parental Preferences for Vesicoureteral Reflux Treatment: A Crowd-sourced, Best-worst Scaling Study. Urology. 2019. PMID: 30878684. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2019.01.045
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。