儿童远端输尿管结石管理的成本效益分析
该研究通过决策树模型比较观察、药物排石治疗(MET)和输尿管镜治疗4毫米远端输尿管结石患儿的成本与临床结局。结果显示输尿管镜成本最高但30天内无痛天数最多(5282美元/29天),MET成本较低但效果较差(615美元/21.8天),观察成本高于MET且效果最差(2139美元/15.5天)。单因素敏感性分析表明输尿管镜始终具有最高净货币效益,推荐作为儿童小远端输尿管结石的治疗策略。
要点
- 输尿管镜成本最高但30天内无痛天数最多,净货币效益最优。
- MET成本低于输尿管镜但效果较差,观察成本高于MET且效果最差。
- 对MET排石成功率进行单因素敏感性分析后,输尿管镜仍为推荐策略。
核心结论
- 输尿管镜是儿童小远端输尿管结石的推荐策略,虽成本最高但30天内无痛天数最多且净货币效益最高。
研究设计与样本
- 开发决策树模型,纳入观察、药物排石治疗(MET)和输尿管镜三种策略,针对4毫米远端输尿管结石的索引患者。
- 概率来源于文献,成本来源于2016年儿科健康信息系统数据库。
- 对MET成功排石概率进行单因素敏感性分析。
主要发现
- 输尿管镜成本最高但30天内无痛天数最多(5282美元/29天)。
- MET成本低于输尿管镜但效果较差(615美元/21.8天)。
- 观察成本高于MET且效果最差(2139美元/15.5天)。
- 单因素敏感性分析显示输尿管镜始终具有最高净货币效益。
临床怎么用
- 对于儿童4毫米远端输尿管结石,在固定支付意愿下优先考虑输尿管镜治疗以最大化30天内无痛天数。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the most cost-effective approach to the management of distal ureteral stones in children given the potential for recurrent renal colic during a trial of passage versus potential stent discomfort and complications of ureteroscopy. METHODS: We developed a decision tree to project costs and clinical outcomes associated with observation, medical explusive therapy (MET), and ureteroscopy for the management of an index patient with a 4-mm-distal ureteral stone. We determined which strategy would be least costly and offer the most pain-free days within 30days of diagnosis. We performed a one-way sensitivity analysis on the probability of successful stone passage with MET. We obtained probabilities from the literature and costs from the 2016 Pediatric Health Information System Database. RESULTS: Ureteroscopy was the costliest strategy but maximized the number of pain-free days within 30days of diagnosis ($5282/29 pain-free days). MET was less costly than ureteroscopy but also less effective ($615/21.8 pain-free days). Observation cost more than MET and was also less effective ($2139/15.5 pain-free days). The one-way sensitivity analysis on the probability of successful stone passage with MET demonstrated that ureteroscopy always has the highest net monetary benefits value and is therefore the recommended strategy given a fixed willingness-to-pay. DISCUSSION: Using a rigorous decision-science approach, we found that ureteroscopy is the recommended strategy in children with small distal ureteral stones. Although it costs more than MET, it resulted in more pain-free days in the first 30days following diagnosis given the faster resolution of the stone episode.
引用
- Chan KH, Whittam BM, Krambeck A, et al. Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of the Management of Distal Ureteral Stones in Children. Urology. 2019. PMID: 30790649. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2019.02.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。