YouTube上前列腺癌错误与偏见信息的传播
该研究对YouTube上首批150条前列腺癌筛查与治疗视频进行质量评估,发现多数视频包含益处信息(75%)多于危害信息(53%),仅50%促进共享决策,且科学质量与观众参与度呈显著负相关(P=0.004)。77%的视频或评论区存在潜在误导或偏见内容,总触达超600万观众。
要点
- YouTube前列腺癌视频整体质量中等,益处信息多于危害信息。
- 科学质量越高,观众参与度越低(P=0.004)。
- 77%视频含潜在误导或偏见内容,触达超600万观众。
核心结论
- 许多流行的YouTube前列腺癌视频包含偏见或低质量信息,高观看和点赞不代表信息可信。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入YouTube上首批150条关于前列腺癌筛查和治疗的视频,使用DISCERN和患者教育材料评估工具进行质量评估。
主要发现
- 描述益处的视频占75%,描述危害的占53%,仅50%促进共享决策。
- 仅54%的视频定义了医学术语,少数提供总结或参考文献。
- 科学质量与观众参与度呈显著负相关(观看/月 P=0.004;点赞/观看 P=0.015)。
- 115条视频(77%)在视频或评论区包含潜在误导和/或偏见内容,总触达超600万观众。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应提醒患者YouTube前列腺癌视频可能存在偏见或低质量信息。
- 不应将高观看量或点赞数作为信息可信度的判断依据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
YouTube is a social media platform with more than 1 billion users and >600000 videos about prostate cancer. Two small studies examined the quality of prostate cancer videos on YouTube, but did not use validated instruments, examine user interactions, or characterize the spread of misinformation. We performed the largest, most comprehensive examination of prostate cancer information on YouTube to date, including the first 150 videos on screening and treatment. We used the validated DISCERN quality criteria for consumer health information and the Patient Education Materials Assessment Tool, and compared results for user engagement. The videos in our sample had up to 1.3 million views (average 45223) and the overall quality of information was moderate. More videos described benefits (75%) than harms (53%), and only 50% promoted shared decision-making as recommended in current guidelines. Only 54% of the videos defined medical terms and few provided summaries or references. There was a significant negative correlation between scientific quality and viewer engagement (views/month p=0.004; thumbs up/views p=0.015). The comments section underneath some videos contained advertising and peer-to-peer medical advice. A total of 115 videos (77%) contained potentially misinformative and/or biased content within the video or comments section, with a total reach of >6 million viewers. PATIENT SUMMARY: Many popular YouTube videos about prostate cancer contained biased or poor-quality information. A greater number of views and thumbs up on YouTube does not mean that the information is trustworthy.
引用
- Loeb S, Sengupta S, Butaney M, et al. Dissemination of Misinformative and Biased Information about Prostate Cancer on YouTube. Eur Urol. 2018. PMID: 30502104. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2018.10.056
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。