机器人辅助与开放简单前列腺切除术的前瞻性对比分析
该前瞻性研究对比了机器人辅助简单前列腺切除术(RASP)与开放简单前列腺切除术(OSP)治疗大体积前列腺增生的效果。结果显示RASP组术中出血量显著更少(539 vs 274 mL),但手术时间更长(134 vs 88 min),两组功能改善相似,RASP安全性良好甚至更优,提示RASP是可行且可能更优的替代方案。
要点
- RASP术中出血量显著低于OSP(539 vs 274 mL),但手术时间更长(134 vs 88 min)。
- OSP组4例(27%)发生严重并发症,RASP组仅1例Clavien-Dindo II级并发症。
- 两组术后IPSS、尿流率和残余尿量均显著改善且组间相似。
核心结论
- RASP提供与OSP相似的功能结局,同时保持良好甚至更好的安全性。
- RASP是可行、有效且可能优于开放手术的替代方案。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性对比分析,2014至2017年两家大学机构共41例因良性前列腺增生手术的患者。
- 按术式分组(OSP或RASP),并按年龄、前列腺体积、体重指数和前列腺特异性抗原水平匹配。
- 两组前瞻性随访3个月,比较术后和功能结局。
主要发现
- OSP组6例(40%)和RASP组7例(27%)术前因复发性尿潴留留置导尿管。
- RASP组术中出血量显著更低(539 vs 274 mL),手术时间显著更长(134 vs 88 min)。
- RASP组1例发生Clavien-Dindo II级并发症;OSP组4例(27%)发生严重并发症:1例膀胱破裂(III级)、1例深静脉血栓(II级)、2例需输血(各1单位,II级)。
- 两组各1例拔管后尿潴留需重新置入导尿管。
- 随访期间两组IPSS、尿流率检查和排尿后残余尿量均显著且相似改善。
临床怎么用
- 对于大体积前列腺增生,RASP可提供与OSP相似的功能结局,且出血更少、严重并发症更少。
- RASP手术时间较长,需权衡其与出血和并发症优势。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To report the first prospective comparative analysis of robot-assisted (RASP) vs open simple prostatectomy (OSP) for large prostate glands. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We prospectively analysed 41 patients who underwent surgery for benign prostatic hyperplasia between 2014 and 2017 at one of two university institutions. Patients were grouped according to the procedure (OSP or RASP) and matched in terms of age, prostate volume, body mass index and prostate-specific antigen level. The two groups were followed prospectively for 3 months, and their postoperative and functional outcomes were compared. RESULTS: Six patients (40%) in the OSP and seven patients (27%) in the RASP arm of the study had preoperative urethral catheters as a result of relapsed urinary retention. The amount of blood loss during surgery was significantly lower in the RASP arm (539 vs 274 mL), but the operating time was significantly longer (134 vs 88 min). One patient in the RASP group experienced a Clavien-Dindo grade II complication, whereas in the OSP group, four patients experienced serious complications (27%); one patient had a bladder rupture (Grade III), one patient developed deep venous thrombosis (Grade II), and two patients required blood transfusions (one unit each; Grade II). Two patients (one from each group) experienced urinary retention after catheter removal that required a urethral catheter replacement. In the follow-up period, there were significant and similar improvements in International Prostate Symptom Scores, uroflowmetry results and post-void residual urine volume in both groups. CONCLUSION: The results showed that RASP provided similar functional outcomes to those of OSP, whilst maintaining a good (or even better) safety profile. Our results suggest that RASP is a viable, efficient and potentially superior alternative to the open procedure.
引用
- Mourmouris P, Keskin SM, Skolarikos A, et al. A prospective comparative analysis of robot-assisted vs open simple prostatectomy for benign prostatic hyperplasia. BJU Int. 2018. PMID: 30198196. doi:10.1111/bju.14531
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。