文献速递前列腺癌

自动性能指标评估机器人膀胱尿道吻合术者表现及培训教程开发

Use of Automated Performance Metrics to Measure Surgeon Performance during Robotic Vesicourethral Anastomosis and Methodical Development of a Training Tutorial.
PubMed 文献 · J Urol · 2018-05-22

该研究旨在开发并验证自动性能指标以评估机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术中膀胱尿道吻合的术者表现,并系统制定标准化培训教程。研究分析70例吻合共1745针,发现专家在完成时间、器械移动效率等自动指标及针持位置、进针角度等非自动指标上均优于新手,随机手势与效率低、尝试多和组织创伤多相关。最终教程含66条陈述和图,8名专家两轮达成共识。

要点

  • 自动性能指标可区分膀胱尿道吻合的专家与新手。
  • 专家技术表现为移动更高效且组织创伤更少。
  • 标准化教程经任务分解、认知任务分析和德尔菲法开发。

核心结论

  • 自动性能指标能够区分膀胱尿道吻合过程中的术者专业水平。
  • 专家膀胱尿道吻合技术表现为移动更高效且组织创伤更少。
  • 标准化机器人膀胱尿道吻合并使用系统开发的教程可能有助于改善机器人手术培训。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究采集机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术中运动追踪和系统事件数据的自动性能指标,并同步手术视频。
  • 非自动性能指标通过视频回顾手动标注。
  • 比较100例或以上操作经验的专家与少于100例的新手之间的自动和非自动性能指标,并对针驱动手势进行分类比较。
  • 应用任务分解、认知任务分析和德尔菲法开发标准化机器人膀胱尿道吻合教程。
  • 分析70例膀胱尿道吻合,共1745针。

主要发现

  • 自动性能指标方面,专家在完成时间(p <0.01)、EndoWrist®关节活动(p <0.03)、器械移动效率(p <0.02)和摄像头操作(p <0.01)上优于新手。
  • 非自动性能指标方面,专家有更优的针与持针器定位、更少的针驱动尝试、更优的进针角度和更少的组织创伤(各p <0.01)。
  • 识别出14种常见的机器人针驱动手势。
  • 随机手势与较低效率(p <0.01)、更多尝试(p <0.04)和更多创伤(p <0.01)相关。
  • 最终教程包含66条陈述和图,8名专家外科医生经过2轮达成共识,其中第1轮后58条(88%)达成共识,第2轮后8条(12%)达成共识。

临床怎么用

  • 自动性能指标可用于评估机器人膀胱尿道吻合的术者表现。
  • 标准化机器人膀胱尿道吻合并采用系统开发的教程可能有助于改善机器人手术培训。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: We sought to develop and validate automated performance metrics to measure surgeon performance of vesicourethral anastomosis during robotic assisted radical prostatectomy. Furthermore, we sought to methodically develop a standardized training tutorial for robotic vesicourethral anastomosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We captured automated performance metrics for motion tracking and system events data, and synchronized surgical video during robotic assisted radical prostatectomy. Nonautomated performance metrics were manually annotated by video review. Automated and nonautomated performance metrics were compared between experts with 100 or more console cases and novices with fewer than 100 cases. Needle driving gestures were classified and compared. We then applied task deconstruction, cognitive task analysis and Delphi methodology to develop a standardized robotic vesicourethral anastomosis tutorial. RESULTS: We analyzed 70 vesicourethral anastomoses with a total of 1,745 stitches. For automated performance metrics experts outperformed novices in completion time (p <0.01), EndoWrist® articulation (p <0.03), instrument movement efficiency (p <0.02) and camera manipulation (p <0.01). For nonautomated performance metrics experts had more optimal needle to needle driver positioning, fewer needle driving attempts, a more optimal needle entry angle and less tissue trauma (each p <0.01). We identified 14 common robotic needle driving gestures. Random gestures were associated with lower efficiency (p <0.01), more attempts (p <0.04) and more trauma (p <0.01). The finalized tutorial contained 66 statements and figures. Consensus among 8 expert surgeons was achieved after 2 rounds, including among 58 (88%) after round 1 and 8 (12%) after round 2. CONCLUSIONS: Automated performance metrics can distinguish surgeon expertise during vesicourethral anastomosis. The expert vesicourethral anastomosis technique was associated with more efficient movement and less tissue trauma. Standardizing robotic vesicourethral anastomosis and using a methodically developed tutorial may help improve robotic surgical training.

来源:J Urol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chen J, Oh PJ, Cheng N, et al. Use of Automated Performance Metrics to Measure Surgeon Performance during Robotic Vesicourethral Anastomosis and Methodical Development of a Training Tutorial. J Urol. 2018. PMID: 29792882. doi:10.1016/j.juro.2018.05.080

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。