一次性数字软性输尿管镜的体外评估与成本分析
该研究在体外比较了LithoVue一次性数字软性输尿管镜与两种可重复使用软镜的技术性能,并分析了可重复使用镜的损坏、耐用性与维护成本。结果显示LithoVue的弯曲、偏转和灌流流量等指标不劣于甚至优于可重复使用镜;234例手术中7条新镜发生15次损坏,鹿角形结石及下盏/中区结石是显著危险因素(P=0.014)。按特定采购价测算,一次性镜可能为医院节省成本。
要点
- LithoVue的弯曲、偏转及灌流流量与可重复使用软镜相当或更优。
- 鹿角形结石及下盏/中区结石是可重复使用软镜损坏的显著危险因素(P=0.014)。
核心结论
- LithoVue在标准技术指标上与可重复使用软性输尿管镜相当。
- 根据其采购成本,一次性镜可能为医院节省成本。
- 泌尿外科医生可考虑在预计可重复使用镜易损坏的病例中使用一次性镜。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究比较LithoVue与Olympus URF-V及Karl Storz Flex-Xc两种可重复使用软性输尿管镜。
- 分析可重复使用输尿管镜的使用情况以评估损坏、耐用性和维护成本。
- 将可重复使用镜成本与一次性镜的预计成本进行比较。
主要发现
- LithoVue的弯曲、偏转和灌流流量与可重复使用软镜相当,甚至更好。
- 234例手术使用7条新Olympus URF-V镜,共发生15次镜体损坏。
- 鹿角形结石和下盏/中区结石是损坏的显著危险因素(P=0.014)。
- 一旦发生损坏,很可能再次发生。
临床怎么用
- 在预计可重复使用镜易损坏的病例(如鹿角形结石、下盏/中区结石)中可考虑使用一次性数字软性输尿管镜。
- 医院决策时应结合一次性镜采购价与可重复使用镜的购买、清洗和维修累计成本进行成本分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess and measure the capability of a single-use disposable digital flexible ureteroscope, the LithoVue™ (Boston Scientific, Marlborough, MA, USA), and to assess if there is a benefit to switching to single-use scopes. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The LithoVue was compared to two commonly used reusable flexible ureteroscopes (Olympus URF-V [Olympus, Tokyo, Japan] and Karl Storz Flex-Xc [Karl Storz & Co. KG, Tuttlingen, Germany]) ex vivo. An analysis of reusable ureteroscope usage was performed to evaluate damage, durability, and maintenance costs. This was then compared to the projected costs of using single-use disposable scopes. RESULTS: Flexion, deflection and irrigation flow of the LithoVue was equivalent, if not better than the reusable flexible ureteroscopes. An analysis of 234 procedures with seven new Olympus URF-V scopes, revealed 15 scope damages. Staghorn stones and lower pole/mid-zone stones were significant risk factors for damage (P = 0.014). Once damage occurred it was likely to occur again. Total repair costs were $162 628 (Australian dollars) (£92 411 in Great British pounds), the mean cost per case was $695 (£395). Factoring in the purchase cost, cleaning and repair costs, the cumulative cost of 28 reusable flexible ureteroscopy procedures was ~$50 000 (£28 412). If the LithoVue was priced at $1 200 (£682), switching to a single-use scope would cost ~$35 000 (£19 888). CONCLUSION: The LithoVue is analogous to reusable flexible ureteroscopes in regard to standard technical metrics. Depending on its purchase cost it may also represent a cost saving for hospitals when compared to the cumulative costs of maintaining reusable scopes. Additionally, urologist may consider using the scope in cases in which reusable scope damage is anticipated.
引用
- Hennessey DB, Fojecki GL, Papa NP, et al. Single-use disposable digital flexible ureteroscopes: an ex vivo assessment and cost analysis. BJU Int. 2018. PMID: 29656467. doi:10.1111/bju.14235
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。