单侧睾丸病变中对侧睾丸固定的实践模式调查
该研究向美国儿科学会泌尿学分会成员发放在线问卷,调查14种可能导致单睾症的临床场景下对侧睾丸固定(CTF)的实践模式。53名受访者中,对新生儿期后睾丸扭转的CTF必要性达成共识,但其他场景(如扭转的未降睾丸、睾丸残迹、可触及萎缩性未降睾丸、单侧钟摆畸形)的共识较低。缺乏强证据是不进行CTF的常见原因。
要点
- 新生儿期后睾丸扭转的CTF必要性获所有受访者共识。
- 产前扭转中84.9%主张CTF,但仅64.4%倾向急诊干预。
- 单侧睾丸肿瘤或外伤需睾丸切除时,主张CTF者分别仅1.9%和9.4%。
核心结论
- 多数受访儿科泌尿外科医生在新生儿扭转中行CTF,新生儿期后扭转的CTF有普遍共识,但其他临床场景仍存争议,需进一步研究。
- CTF决策应涉及患者、家长及治疗医生。
研究设计与样本
- 在线问卷调查美国儿科学会泌尿学分会成员,包含14种临床场景的CTF实践问题,匿名提交、盲法审阅和分析。
- 共53名受访者,62.3%有学术任职,73.6%从事纯儿科泌尿外科实践。
主要发现
- 所有参与者同意新生儿期后睾丸扭转需行CTF。
- 产前扭转中84.9%主张CTF,64.4%倾向急诊干预;产后扭转中96.2%主张CTF,98%倾向急诊干预;延迟就诊扭转中94.3%主张CTF。
- 单侧睾丸肿瘤中仅1.9%(1人)倾向CTF,外伤需睾丸切除中仅9.4%(5人)倾向CTF。
- 扭转的未降睾丸中,青春期前79.3%、青春期后81.13%主张CTF;儿童睾丸残迹中40.4%主张CTF;可触及萎缩性未降睾丸中13.2%主张CTF;单侧钟摆畸形中47.2%主张CTF。
- 非扭转场景下不进行CTF的最常见原因是缺乏强证据。
临床怎么用
- 对于新生儿期后睾丸扭转,应行对侧睾丸固定。
- 在非扭转场景(如睾丸肿瘤、外伤、睾丸残迹、萎缩性未降睾丸、钟摆畸形)中,CTF决策需个体化,并充分结合患者、家长及医生的意见。
局限性
- 样本量较小(53名受访者),可能不能代表所有儿科泌尿外科医生。
- 调查基于问卷,存在应答偏倚可能。
- 未报告应答率及受访者地理分布等细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To query the current contralateral testis fixation (CTF) practice patterns among pediatric urologists in different clinical situations that could result in monorchism. METHODS: An online survey was sent to members of the Urology Section of the American Academy of Pediatrics. The survey included questions addressing CTF practice patterns in 14 clinical scenarios. Responses were anonymously submitted, blindly reviewed, and analyzed. RESULTS: Among 53 respondents, 62.3% had academic appointments and 73.6% had an exclusive pediatric urology practice. All participants agreed on CTF necessity in testicular torsion beyond the neonatal period. CTF was advocated by 84.9% in prenatal torsion, 96.2% in postnatal torsion, and 94.3% in delayed torsion presentation. Emergent intervention was favored by 64.4% in prenatal and 98% in postnatal torsion. Only 1 participant (1.9%) preferred CTF with a unilateral testicular tumor and 5 (9.4%) in trauma substantiating an orchiectomy. There was less consensus on CTF in torsed undescended testis (79.3% in prepubertal and 81.13% in postpubertal), testicular nubbin in a child (40.4%), palpable atrophic undescended testis (13.2%), and unilateral bell-clapper anomaly (47.2%). In situations other than torsion, lack of strong evidence was the commonest reason not to perform CTF. CONCLUSION: The majority of responding pediatric urologists currently performs CTF in neonatal torsion. Although there is a general consensus on CTF in testicular torsion outside the neonatal period, CTF remains controversial in other clinical situations, warranting further research. The decision for CTF should involve patients, parents, and treating physicians.
引用
- Abdelhalim A, Chamberlin JD, McAleer IM, et al. A Survey of the Current Practice Patterns of Contralateral Testis Fixation in Unilateral Testicular Conditions. Urology. 2018. PMID: 29572060. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2018.03.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。