硅胶肾肿瘤模型在机器人部分肾切除术培训中的开发与效度验证
本研究利用患者肾脏肿瘤的3D打印模具制作硅胶肾肿瘤模型,并评估其表面效度、内容效度和结构效度。24名不同培训级别的手术医生完成4次模拟训练,专家对模型真实性和训练有用性的评分均值分别为79.2和90.2。培训级别更高的医生在肾动脉阻断时间和GEARS评分上显著更优,且多项指标随训练次数改善。
要点
- 硅胶肾肿瘤模型在专家评分中显示出良好的真实性和训练有用性。
- 培训级别更高的医生在肾动脉阻断时间和GEARS评分上显著更优。
- 肾动脉阻断时间、保留肾实质、切缘阳性、NASA TLX和GEARS评分随训练次数显著改善。
核心结论
- 硅胶肾肿瘤模型在不同培训级别医生中展示了表面效度、内容效度和结构效度。
- 专家认为该模型有用且真实,培训级别更高的医生表现更优,且个体表现随训练次数改善。
研究设计与样本
- 利用患者肾脏肿瘤的3D打印模具制作硅胶肾肿瘤模型,评估其表面效度、内容效度和结构效度。
- 24名参与者包括主治泌尿外科医生、泌尿内镜研究员、泌尿外科住院医师和医学生,完成4次模拟训练。
主要发现
- 专家培训后调查显示,模型整体触感真实性均值为79.2,训练整体有用性均值为90.2。
- 培训级别更高的医生肾动脉阻断时间显著更优(P ≤ .005),GEARS评分显著更优(P ≤ .025)。
- 肾动脉阻断时间、保留肾实质、切缘阳性、NASA TLX和GEARS评分随训练次数改善(P < .001、P = .025、P = .024、P ≤ .020、P ≤ .006)。
关键数值与推荐
- 专家对模型整体触感真实性评分均值79.2,对训练整体有用性评分均值90.2。
- 培训级别更高的医生肾动脉阻断时间P ≤ .005,GEARS评分P ≤ .025。
- 肾动脉阻断时间随训练次数P < .001,保留肾实质P = .025,切缘阳性P = .024,NASA TLX P ≤ .020,GEARS评分P ≤ .006。
临床怎么用
- 该硅胶肾肿瘤模型可作为机器人部分肾切除术的培训工具,适用于不同培训级别医生。
- 模型可重复使用,支持多次模拟训练以改善手术指标。
局限性
- 未来研究应评估模型的预测效度,即模型表现改善与真实手术改善之间的关联。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To provide a training tool to address the technical challenges of robot-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy, we created silicone renal tumor models using 3-dimensional printed molds of a patient's kidney with a mass. In this study, we assessed the face, content, and construct validity of these models. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Surgeons of different training levels completed 4 simulations on silicone renal tumor models. Participants were surveyed on the usefulness and realism of the model as a training tool. Performance was measured using operation-specific metrics, self-reported operative demands (NASA Task Load Index [NASA TLX]), and blinded expert assessment (Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Surgeons [GEARS]). RESULTS: Twenty-four participants included attending urologists, endourology fellows, urology residents, and medical students. Post-training surveys of expert participants yielded mean results of 79.2 on the realism of the model's overall feel and 90.2 on the model's overall usefulness for training. Renal artery clamp times and GEARS scores were significantly better in surgeons further in training (P ≤.005 and P ≤.025). Renal artery clamp times, preserved renal parenchyma, positive margins, NASA TLX, and GEARS scores were all found to improve across trials (P <.001, P = .025, P = .024, P ≤.020, and P ≤.006, respectively). CONCLUSION: Face, content, and construct validity were demonstrated in the use of a silicone renal tumor model in a cohort of surgeons of different training levels. Expert participants deemed the model useful and realistic. Surgeons of higher training levels performed better than less experienced surgeons in various study metrics, and improvements within individuals were observed over sequential trials. Future studies should aim to assess model predictive validity, namely, the association between model performance improvements and improvements in live surgery.
引用
- Monda SM, Weese JR, Anderson BG, et al. Development and Validity of a Silicone Renal Tumor Model for Robotic Partial Nephrectomy Training. Urology. 2018. PMID: 29421300. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2018.01.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。