耻骨上膀胱造瘘尿道休息对 obliterative 或近 obliterative 尿道狭窄的尿道造影变化及治疗影响
研究纳入29例前尿道狭窄男性,在耻骨上膀胱造瘘前后行逆行尿道造影和排尿期膀胱尿道造影,随机选20对由11名重建泌尿外科医生解读。造瘘后狭窄闭塞比例从23%升至58%(p=0.0005),47%手术方案改变,其中37%改为切除吻合。
要点
- 耻骨上膀胱造瘘后狭窄闭塞判定比例由23%升至58%(p=0.0005)。
- 术后影像狭窄长度平均3.0±2.6 cm,术中3.8±3.3 cm(p<0.0001)。
- 47%病例手术方案改变,37%改为切除吻合。
核心结论
- 耻骨上膀胱造瘘尿道休息后更多狭窄表现为闭塞,约半数病例手术方案改变。
- 影像评估仍平均低估狭窄长度近1 cm,短狭窄低估较少,长狭窄低估增加。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性维护数据库查询,纳入29例前尿道狭窄男性,随机选20对造瘘前后影像。
- 由11名经过 fellowship 培训的重建泌尿外科医生随机顺序解读,比较造瘘前后狭窄长度、直径、位置及手术计划。
主要发现
- 解读医生间影像一致性满意(ICC 0.72)。
- 造瘘前后狭窄长度无统计学显著差异。
- 造瘘前23%影像判为闭塞,造瘘后58%判为闭塞(p=0.0005)。
- 造瘘后影像狭窄长度平均3.0±2.6 cm,术中3.8±3.3 cm(p<0.0001)。
- 影像与术中长度偏差随狭窄长度增加(斜率0.26,p=0.0023)。
关键数值与推荐
- 狭窄长度比较:造瘘前 vs 造瘘后无统计学显著差异。
- 闭塞判定比例:造瘘前23% vs 造瘘后58%(p=0.0005)。
- 影像与术中长度偏差随狭窄长度增加:斜率0.26(p=0.0023)。
临床怎么用
- 对高级别狭窄行尿道成形术前放置耻骨上膀胱造瘘行尿道休息,可更频繁显示闭塞并影响手术方案。
- 若未放置耻骨上膀胱造瘘,手术方案应考虑到狭窄可能比影像显示更紧。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Precise preoperative characterization of urethral stricture is important for surgical planning. A period of urethral rest by a suprapubic cystostomy tube may aid in stricture characterization and affect the surgical approach. In this study fellowship trained reconstructive urologists compared the radiographic characterization of anterior urethral strictures before and after a period of urethral rest. We then determined how this changed the planned operative approach. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We queried our prospectively maintained urethroplasty database at our institution for men with an anterior urethral stricture who underwent retrograde urethrogram and voiding cystourethrogram before and after preoperative suprapubic cystostomy tube placement. A total of 29 men were identified for analysis. To minimize responder fatigue 20 pairs of radiographs were selected at random. All images before and after suprapubic tube placement were interpreted in random order by 11 fellowship trained reconstructive urologists. Interpretation included stricture length, diameter, location and surgeon operative plan. Preplacement and post-placement results were compared. Post-placement stricture length was also compared to intraoperative length. ICC was used to evaluate homogeneity among the urologists. Linear regression analysis was performed to determine the association of post-radiographic length after tube placement with intraoperative stricture length. RESULTS: Imaging agreement among interpreting urologists was satisfactory (ICC 0.72). There was no statistically significant difference in stricture length before vs after suprapubic tube placement. Of the images 23% were considered obliterative before tube placement while 58% were obliterative after placement (p = 0.0005). Mean ± SD post-placement radiographic and intraoperative stricture length was 3.0 ± 2.6 and 3.8 ± 3.3 cm, respectively (p <0.0001). Deviation between the radiographic and intraoperative lengths increased with stricture length (slope 0.26, p = 0.0023). The surgeon operative plan changed 47% of the time, including to an excision approach in 37% of cases. CONCLUSIONS: Despite optimal urethral imaging with a suprapubic tube in men with high grade stricture reconstructive urologists underestimated length by an average of almost 1 cm. This underestimation was less for shorter strictures and it increased with stricture length. In addition, a period of urethral rest resulted in more frequent stricture obliteration, which was associated with a change in the planned operative approach about half of the time. If urologists do not place a suprapubic cystostomy tube prior to urethroplasty for high grade stricture, the operative plan should account for the stricture being tighter than it may appear.
引用
- Moncrief T, Gor R, Goldfarb RA, et al. Urethral Rest with Suprapubic Cystostomy for Obliterative or Nearly Obliterative Urethral Strictures: Urethrographic Changes and Implications for Management. J Urol. 2017. PMID: 29221931. doi:10.1016/j.juro.2017.11.110
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。