机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术客观性能指标的建立与验证:一项先导研究
本研究利用新型记录器dVLogger直接采集da Vinci手术系统上术者的操作数据,在机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术的预设步骤中比较专家与新手,开展结构效度与同时效度验证。专家完成各步骤更快、器械移动距离更短、器械闲置总时间更少、镜头路径更短且镜头移动更频繁;运动学指标与GEARS评分的关联有限。
要点
- 专家完成预设手术步骤更快,器械移动距离与闲置时间更少
- 除前部膀胱尿道吻合外,专家优势手与非优势手器械路径距离比值更大
- 前部膀胱尿道吻合与精囊游离的运动学指标与GEARS评分关联有限
核心结论
- 客观指标显示专家在机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术的预设步骤中更高效、更有方向性。
- 客观指标与GEARS的关联有限。
- 这些发现为开发用于术者培训和评估的标准化指标奠定基础。
研究设计与样本
- 利用新型记录器dVLogger直接采集术者在da Vinci手术系统上的操作,开展结构效度与同时效度验证的先导研究。
- 比较专家(100例或以上)与新手(少于100例)在膀胱游离、精囊游离、前部膀胱尿道吻合和右侧盆腔淋巴结清扫中的运动学与事件数据。
- 采用混合效应统计模型比较专家与新手指标(结构效度)。
- 由专家评审者使用GEARS(机器人技能整体评估)对精囊游离和前部膀胱尿道吻合进行盲法评分,并以组内相关系数衡量评分者间变异。
- 采用Spearman检验将客观指标与相应GEARS指标做相关分析(同时效度)。
主要发现
- 共评估100例机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术中10名专家(平均810例,范围100至2,000)与10名新手(平均35例,范围5至80)的表现。
- 结构效度方面,专家完成手术步骤更快(p <0.001),器械移动距离更短(p <0.01),器械闲置总时间更少(p <0.001),镜头路径长度更短(p <0.001),镜头移动更频繁(p <0.03)。
- 除前部膀胱尿道吻合外,专家在所有步骤中优势手与非优势手器械路径距离比值更大(p <0.04)。
- 同时效度方面,3名专家评审者的中位经验为300例(范围200至500),评审者间组内相关系数为0.6至0.7。
- 对于前部膀胱尿道吻合和精囊游离,运动学指标与GEARS指标的关联较低。
关键数值与推荐
- 专家定义:100例或以上;新手定义:少于100例。
- 专家平均810例(范围100至2,000),新手平均35例(范围5至80)。
- 专家完成步骤更快(p <0.001)、器械移动距离更短(p <0.01)、器械闲置总时间更少(p <0.001)、镜头路径长度更短(p <0.001)、镜头移动更频繁(p <0.03)。
- 除前部膀胱尿道吻合外,专家优势手与非优势手器械路径距离比值更大(p <0.04)。
- 3名专家评审者中位经验300例(范围200至500),评审者间组内相关系数0.6至0.7。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We explore and validate objective surgeon performance metrics using a novel recorder ("dVLogger") to directly capture surgeon manipulations on the da Vinci® Surgical System. We present the initial construct and concurrent validation study of objective metrics during preselected steps of robot-assisted radical prostatectomy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Kinematic and events data were recorded for expert (100 or more cases) and novice (less than 100 cases) surgeons performing bladder mobilization, seminal vesicle dissection, anterior vesicourethral anastomosis and right pelvic lymphadenectomy. Expert/novice metrics were compared using mixed effect statistical modeling (construct validation). Expert reviewers blindly rated seminal vesicle dissection and anterior vesicourethral anastomosis using GEARS (Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Skills). Intraclass correlation measured inter-rater variability. Objective metrics were correlated to corresponding GEARS metrics using Spearman's test (concurrent validation). RESULTS: The performance of 10 experts (mean 810 cases, range 100 to 2,000) and 10 novices (mean 35 cases, range 5 to 80) was evaluated in 100 robot-assisted radical prostatectomy cases. For construct validation the experts completed operative steps faster (p <0.001) with less instrument travel distance (p <0.01), less aggregate instrument idle time (p <0.001), shorter camera path length (p <0.001) and more frequent camera movements (p <0.03). Experts had a greater ratio of dominant-to-nondominant instrument path distance for all steps (p <0.04) except anterior vesicourethral anastomosis. For concurrent validation the median experience of 3 expert reviewers was 300 cases (range 200 to 500). Intraclass correlation among reviewers was 0.6-0.7. For anterior vesicourethral anastomosis and seminal vesicle dissection, kinematic metrics had low associations with GEARS metrics. CONCLUSIONS: Objective metrics revealed experts to be more efficient and directed during preselected steps of robot-assisted radical prostatectomy. Objective metrics had limited associations to GEARS. These findings lay the foundation for developing standardized metrics for surgeon training and assessment.
引用
- Hung AJ, Chen J, Jarc A, et al. Development and Validation of Objective Performance Metrics for Robot-Assisted Radical Prostatectomy: A Pilot Study. J Urol. 2017. PMID: 28765067. doi:10.1016/j.juro.2017.07.081
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。