MRI-超声融合穿刺加入后符合主动监测标准患者的重分类率:7种常用标准的分析
该研究纳入因前列腺癌评估接受融合穿刺、且仅基于标准12针穿刺符合7种主动监测(AS)标准中至少1种的患者,评估加入MRI-超声融合穿刺针后AS资格的变化。共100名患者符合至少1种AS标准,加入融合穿刺针后失去AS资格的比例为10.3%至40.7%;采用阳性针数百分比而非绝对针数可减少排除人数。作者认为融合穿刺显著增加了失去AS资格的人数,AS标准可能需要更新以避免因低风险病变过度采样而不必要地排除患者。
要点
- 加入融合穿刺针后,符合至少1种AS标准者中失去资格的比例为10.3%至40.7%。
- 采用阳性针数绝对上限的AS标准,失去资格率最高。
- 采用阳性针数百分比可减少被排除的患者人数。
核心结论
- 在标准12针穿刺基础上加入融合穿刺针显著增加了失去主动监测资格的患者人数。
- 采用阳性针数百分比而非绝对针数允许较少的排除。
- 主动监测标准可能需要更新,以避免因低风险病变过度采样而不必要地排除患者。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入因前列腺癌评估接受融合穿刺、且仅基于标准穿刺符合7种不同主动监测标准中至少1种的患者。
- 对每名患者分别评估包含与不包含融合穿刺针时是否符合每种主动监测标准。
- 主要终点为最初符合主动监测但加入融合穿刺针后失去资格的患者比例。
主要发现
- 共100名患者符合至少1种主动监测标准。
- 加入融合穿刺针后,失去主动监测资格的患者比例范围为10.3%至40.7%。
- 采用阳性针数绝对上限的标准,失去资格率最高。
- 采用阳性针数百分比有助于减少被排除的患者人数。
- 将靶向穿刺针合并为一针,或取分级或体积最高的单针,似乎未减少失去资格的患者比例。
关键数值与推荐
- 共评估7种广泛使用的主动监测标准。
- 加入融合穿刺针后失去主动监测资格的患者比例范围为10.3%至40.7%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the impact of adding magnetic resonance imaging-ultrasound (MRI-US) fusion biopsy cores to standard 12-core biopsy in selecting men for active surveillance (AS). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Among men undergoing a fusion biopsy for evaluation of prostate cancer, we selected men who were eligible for at least 1 of 7 different AS criteria based on the standard biopsy alone. We assessed each patient's eligibility for each AS criterion with and without the inclusion of fusion biopsy cores. The primary end point was the proportion of men who were initially eligible for AS but became ineligible after addition of the fusion biopsy cores. RESULTS: A total of 100 men were eligible for at least 1 AS criterion. After addition of fusion biopsy cores, the proportion of men who became ineligible for AS varied from 10.3% to 40.7%. Criteria that incorporated an absolute maximum number of cores positive had the highest rates of ineligibility. Using a percentage of cores positive helped to reduce the number of patients who would have been excluded. Combining the targeted biopsy cores into one, or taking the single core with the highest grade or volume did not appear to reduce the proportion of men who became ineligible. CONCLUSIONS: The addition of fusion biopsy to standard 12-core biopsy significantly increased the number of men who became ineligible for AS. Using the percent of cores positive, instead of an absolute number, allowed fewer exclusions. AS criteria may need to be updated to prevent the unnecessary exclusion of men due to an oversampling of low-risk disease.
引用
- Nahar B, Katims A, Barboza MP, et al. Reclassification Rates of Patients Eligible for Active Surveillance After the Addition of Magnetic Resonance Imaging-Ultrasound Fusion Biopsy: An Analysis of 7 Widely Used Eligibility Criteria. Urology. 2017. PMID: 28842208. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2017.08.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。