文献速递泌尿系结石

输尿管镜与冲击波碎石术治疗上段输尿管结石的获益与危害比较:系统综述

What are the Benefits and Harms of Ureteroscopy Compared with Shock-wave Lithotripsy in the Treatment of Upper Ureteral Stones? A Systematic Review.
PubMed 文献 · Eur Urol · 2017-04-26

该系统综述检索2000年1月至2014年11月文献,纳入47项研究(19项为随机对照试验),比较输尿管镜(URS)与冲击波碎石术(SWL)治疗上段输尿管结石的获益与危害。因数据异质性未行Meta分析;URS在≤4周结石清除率更高,但3个月时差异不显著,且并发症更多、住院更长。

要点

  • 与SWL相比,URS在≤4周结石清除率更高,但3个月时差异不显著。
  • SWL再治疗率更高,URS辅助操作(如JJ支架置入)更多、并发症率更高、住院更长。
  • 两种治疗均为安全有效的选择,应基于患者个体情况和偏好提供。

核心结论

  • 与SWL相比,URS在≤4周结石清除率显著更高,但纳入研究中3个月时差异不显著。
  • URS与更少的再治疗和二次手术需求相关,但辅助操作需求更高、并发症率更高、住院时间更长。
  • 两种治疗均为安全有效的选择,应基于患者个体情况和偏好提供。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述检索Medline、Embase和Cochrane图书馆2000年1月至2014年11月文献。
  • 纳入比较URS与SWL任何亚型或变异的随机对照试验、准随机对照试验和非随机研究。
  • 22项研究比较URS与SWL(4项随机对照试验、1项准随机对照试验、17项非随机研究);25项研究为组内比较。
  • 无儿童研究符合纳入标准;因数据异质性未行Meta分析。

主要发现

  • 22项比较研究中9项结石清除率 favoring URS。
  • 除一项研究外,所有研究中SWL再治疗率高于URS。
  • 以URS为主要治疗时住院时间更长且辅助操作(最常见为JJ支架置入)更常见。
  • 22项研究中11项报告并发症,其中8项可按Clavien-Dindo分级报告;URS所有级别并发症率均高于SWL。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论指出两种治疗均为安全有效的选择,应基于患者个体情况和偏好提供。

局限性

  • 因数据异质性未行Meta分析。
  • 25项组内比较研究结局指标差异大且数据异质性高。
  • 无儿童研究符合纳入标准。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

CONTEXT: Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) and ureteroscopy (URS), with or without intracorporeal lithotripsy, are the most common treatments for upper ureteric stones. With advances in technology, it is unclear which treatment is most effective and/or safest. OBJECTIVE: To systematically review literature reporting benefits and harms of SWL and URS in the management of upper ureteric stones. EVIDENCE ACQUISITION: Databases including Medline, Embase, and the Cochrane library were searched from January 2000 to November 2014. All randomised controlled trials (RCTs), quasi-randomised controlled trials, and nonrandomised studies comparing any subtype or variation of URS and SWL were included. The primary benefit outcome was stone-free rate (SFR). The primary harm outcome was complications. Secondary outcomes included retreatment rate, need for secondary, and/or adjunctive procedures. The Cochrane risk of bias tool was used to assess RCTs, and an extended version was used to assess nonrandomised studies. Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation was used to assess the quality of evidence. EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS: Five thousand-three hundred and eighty abstracts and 387 full-text articles were screened. Forty-seven studies met inclusion criteria; 19 (39.6%) were RCTs. No studies on children met inclusion criteria. URS and SWL were compared in 22 studies (4 RCTs, 1 quasi-randomised controlled trial, and 17 nonrandomised studies). Meta-analyses were inappropriate due to data heterogeneity. SFR favoured URS in 9/22 studies. Retreatment rates were higher for SWL compared with URS in all studies but one. Longer hospital stay and adjunctive procedures (most commonly the insertion of a JJ stent) were more common when primary treatment was URS. Complications were reported in 11 out of 22 studies. In eight studies, it was possible to report this as a Clavien-Dindo Grade. Higher complication rates across all grades were reported for URS compared with SWL. For intragroup (intra-SWL and intra-URS) comparative studies, 25 met the inclusion criteria. These studies varied greatly in outcomes measured with data being heterogeneous. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with SWL, URS was associated with a significantly greater SFR up to 4 wk but the difference was not significant at 3 mo in the included studies. URS was associated with fewer retreatments and need for secondary procedures, but with a higher need for adjunctive procedures, greater complication rates, and longer hospital stay. PATIENT SUMMARY: In this paper, the relative benefits and harms of the two most commonly offered treatment options for urinary stones located in the upper ureter were reviewed. We found that both treatments are safe and effective options that should be offered based on individual patient circumstances and preferences.

来源:Eur Urol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Drake T, Grivas N, Dabestani S, et al. What are the Benefits and Harms of Ureteroscopy Compared with Shock-wave Lithotripsy in the Treatment of Upper Ureteral Stones? A Systematic Review. Eur Urol. 2017. PMID: 28456350. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2017.04.016

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。