解剖复杂肾肿块治疗中部分与根治性肾切除术风险获益权衡的协作综述
该协作综述评估了解剖复杂或较大肾肿块患者行部分肾切除术(PN)与根治性肾切除术(RN)的对比证据。PN可保留肾实质但围手术期风险可能高于RN,而RN可能放弃保留肾的长期获益;现有高质量对比证据稀少,回顾性比较存在选择偏倚,唯一的前瞻性随机试验提示保留肾单位手术可能并非对所有患者均获益。
要点
- 解剖复杂或较大肾肿块行PN可能面临围手术期及潜在肿瘤学风险,而RN可能放弃保留肾的长期获益。
- 现有高质量对比有效性证据稀少,回顾性比较受选择偏倚困扰。
- 唯一的前瞻性随机试验虽不完美,但提示保留肾单位手术可能并非对所有患者均获益。
核心结论
- 对于解剖复杂肿瘤,PN可保留肾实质但可能使患者面临比RN更高的围手术期风险。
- 需更好地客观化每种手术的风险与获益,以识别最适合复杂PN的患者。
- 有必要开展前瞻性随机试验,以帮助指导患者咨询。
研究设计与样本
- 对医学文献进行的协作批判性综述。
主要发现
- 接受PN的解剖复杂或较大肿块患者可能暴露于围手术期和潜在肿瘤学风险,而若行RN则可避免这些风险。
- 接受RN的患者可能放弃保留肾的长期获益。
- 关于PN或RN最佳治疗的决策高度微妙,必须平衡每种方法的风险与获益。
- 当前高质量对比有效性证据稀少;回顾性比较受选择偏倚困扰。
- 唯一现有的前瞻性随机试验虽不完美,但提示保留肾单位手术可能并非对所有患者均获益。
临床怎么用
- 复杂肾肿块的治療决策需要就部分与根治性肾切除术之间的风险权衡进行共享决策。
局限性
- 当前高质量对比有效性证据稀少。
- 回顾性比较受选择偏倚困扰。
- 唯一现有的前瞻性随机试验虽不完美。
- 有必要开展前瞻性随机试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: While partial nephrectomy (PN) is the recommended treatment for many small renal masses, anatomically complex tumors necessitate a clear understanding of the potential risks and benefits of PN and radical nephrectomy (RN). OBJECTIVE: To critically review the comparative effectiveness evidence of PN versus RN; to describe key trade-offs involved in this treatment decision; and to highlight gaps in the current literature. EVIDENCE ACQUISITION: A collaborative critical review of the medical literature was conducted. EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS: Patients who undergo PN for an anatomically complex or large mass may be exposed to perioperative and potential oncologic risks that could be avoided if RN were performed, while patients who undergo RN may forgo long-term benefits of renal preservation. Decision-making regarding the optimal treatment with PN or RN among patients with anatomically complex or large renal mass is highly nuanced and must balance the risks and benefits of each approach. Currently, high-quality evidence on comparative effectiveness is sparse. Retrospective comparisons are plagued by selection biases, while the one existing prospective randomized trial, albeit imperfect, suggests that nephron-sparing surgery may not benefit all patients. CONCLUSIONS: For anatomically complex tumors, PN preserves renal parenchyma but may expose patients to higher perioperative risks than RN. The risks and benefits of each surgical approach must be better objectified for identification of patients most suitable for complex PN. A prospective randomized trial is warranted and would help in directing patient counseling. PATIENT SUMMARY: Treatment decisions for complex renal masses require shared decision-making regarding the risk trade-offs between partial and radical nephrectomy.
引用
- Kim SP, Campbell SC, Gill I, et al. Collaborative Review of Risk Benefit Trade-offs Between Partial and Radical Nephrectomy in the Management of Anatomically Complex Renal Masses. Eur Urol. 2016. PMID: 27988238. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2016.11.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。