老年T1-T2期肾脏肿物行肾部分切除术与根治性肾切除术的比较:并发症、肾功能与肿瘤学结局
本研究基于本机构肾脏肿物登记数据库,比较65岁及以上cT1-T2期单发肾脏肿物患者行肾部分切除术(PN)与根治性肾切除术(RN)的结局。共纳入787例,PN组437例(55.5%),RN组350例(44.5%),中位随访36个月。PN组估算肾小球滤过率(eGFR)下降幅度小于RN组(6.4 vs 19.7,P < .001),两组并发症发生率相似(37.8% vs 38.9%),总生存期与癌症特异性生存期相当。
要点
- PN组末次随访eGFR下降6.4,RN组下降19.7(P < .001)。
- PN组并发症发生率37.8%,RN组38.9%,两组相似。
- 两组总生存期与癌症特异性生存期相当。
核心结论
- 这些数据提示老年患者行PN未受损害并可能潜在获益,年龄本身不应成为保留肾单位手术的禁忌证。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究查询本机构肾脏肿物登记数据库,纳入65岁及以上、行PN或RN切除的单发cT1-T2期肾脏肿物患者787例,其中PN组437例(55.5%),RN组350例(44.5%),中位随访36个月。
主要发现
- PN组患者较RN组更年轻(中位年龄70.3岁 vs 71.9岁,P < .001),美国麻醉医师协会评分更低(2.6 vs 2.8,P = .001),肿瘤更小(肿瘤直径2.8 cm vs 5.0 cm,P < .001),肾细胞癌比例更低(76.7% vs 87.4%,P < .001)。
- PN组与RN组围手术期结局相似,并发症发生率分别为37.8%与38.9%。
- 末次随访时PN组eGFR估算变化为6.4,RN组为19.7(P < .001)。
- 两种术式的总生存期与癌症特异性生存期相当。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,鉴于PN的肾功能获益需多年才能体现且该手术历史并发症率高于RN,部分疑似老年患者可能从RN而非PN中获益更多;但这些数据提示老年患者行PN未受损害并可能潜在获益,年龄本身不应成为保留肾单位手术的禁忌证。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare outcomes of partial nephrectomy (PN) and radical nephrectomy (RN) in patients 65 years and older. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Our institutional renal mass registry was queried for patients 65 and older with solitary cT1-T2 renal mass resected by PN or RN. Clinicopathologic features and perioperative outcomes were compared between groups. Renal function outcomes measured by change in estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) and freedom from eGFR< 45 mL/min/1.73 m2 were analyzed. Multivariate Cox proportional hazard models for overall survival and cancer-specific survival were analyzed. RESULTS: Overall, 787 patients met inclusion criteria. Of these, 437 (55.5%) underwent PN and 350 (44.5%) underwent RN. Median follow-up was 36 months. Patients in the PN cohort were younger (median age 70.3 years vs 71.9 years, P < .001), had lower American Society of Anesthesiologists scores (2.6 vs 2.8, P = .001), smaller tumors (tumor diameter 2.8 cm vs 5.0 cm, P < .001), and lower proportion of renal cell carcinoma (76.7% vs 87.4%, P < .001). Perioperative outcomes were similar between PN and RN groups as were complications (37.8% vs 38.9%). Estimated change in eGFR was less in PN vs RN (6.4 vs 19.7, P < .001) at last follow-up. Overall survival and cancer-specific survival were equivalent between modalities. CONCLUSION: Because the renal functional benefit of PN is realized over many years and the procedure has a higher historical complication rate than RN, some suspected elderly patients might benefit more from RN over PN. However, these data suggest that elderly patients are not harmed and may potentially benefit from PN. Age alone should not be a contraindication to nephron-sparing surgery.
引用
- An JY, Ball MW, Gorin MA, et al. Partial vs Radical Nephrectomy for T1-T2 Renal Masses in the Elderly: Comparison of Complications, Renal Function, and Oncologic Outcomes. Urology. 2016. PMID: 27889493. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2016.10.047
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。