肾癌患者运动、营养与心理支持的预康复和康复干预:范围综述
本范围综述遵循PRISMA-ScR指南,检索2004年1月至2022年3月RCT,纳入18项RCT共2774名受试者(其中706例肾癌患者/幸存者),评估预康复/康复运动、营养及心理支持干预。大多数(14/18)RCT显示统计学显著阳性结果,心理支持尤其是正念干预证据最稳健,其次为运动联合/不联合心理支持,营养或药物干预证据较弱。
要点
- 心理支持尤其正念干预证据最稳健(9/10研究主要结局显著改善)。
- 治疗性运动联合/不联合心理支持在5/8项RCT中显示有效。
- 营养或药物干预仅2/5项RCT显示有效。
核心结论
- 大多数(14/18)RCT显示运动、营养、心理支持或预康复/康复项目对肾癌患者有统计学显著阳性结果。
- 心理支持尤其是正念干预证据最稳健,其次为治疗性运动联合/不联合心理支持,营养或药物干预证据较弱。
- Level 1证据支持向患者提供咨询并转介正念心理治疗联合物理治疗/康复医学,以及考虑术前碳水化合物饮料。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA-ScR指南的范围综述,检索2004年1月至2022年3月RCT。
- 纳入18项RCT,共2774名受试者,其中706例为肾癌患者/幸存者。
- 干预包括预康复或康复、运动、心理支持或营养组分,对象为肾癌患者或照顾者。
主要发现
- 2项干预在术前实施,1项在系统治疗开始前,8项在系统或放疗期间,3项在治疗后,4项未说明实施时间。
- 心理支持(尤其正念干预)在9/10项研究中主要结局显著改善。
- 治疗性运动联合/不联合心理支持在5/8项RCT中显示有效。
- 营养或药物干预在2/5项RCT中显示有效。
关键数值与推荐
- 心理支持(尤其正念干预):9/10项研究显示主要结局统计学显著阳性改善。
- 治疗性运动联合/不联合心理支持:5/8项RCT显示有效。
- 营养或药物干预:2/5项RCT显示有效。
- Level 1证据支持咨询并转介正念心理治疗联合物理治疗/康复医学,以及考虑术前碳水化合物饮料。
临床怎么用
- 可向肾癌患者提供咨询并转介正念心理治疗联合物理治疗或康复医学。
- 可考虑术前碳水化合物饮料。
- 治疗性运动联合/不联合心理支持可作为有效的康复干预。
局限性
- 无研究纳入照顾者或评估成本效果。
- 部分干预实施时间未明确报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To comprehensively review the available literature on prehabilitation and rehabilitation exercise, nutrition, and psychological support interventions for patients with kidney cancer (KC), to summarise the clinically relevant efficacy and cost-effectiveness of interventions, to expose key knowledge gaps, and to inform future investigations and initiatives. METHODS: This review was performed according to the per Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) Extension for Scoping Reviews Guidelines. We included randomised controlled trials (RCTs) assessing programmes of prehabilitation or rehabilitation, exercise, psychological support, or nutrition components in patients with KC or KC caregivers from January 2004 to March 2022. Statistically significant positive (SS+) and negative (SS-) results were summarised. RESULTS: The systematic search yielded 10 968 records including 18 RCTs, involving 2774 unique subjects, 706 of whom were KC patients/survivors. None included caregivers or assessed cost-effectiveness. Two interventions were implemented before surgery, one was implemented prior to initiation of systemic therapy, eight were implemented during systemic or radiation therapy, three were implemented after treatment, while implementation time was not specified for four interventions. CONCLUSION: Most (14/18) RCTs involving exercise, nutrition, psychological support, or prehabilitative or rehabilitative programmes for KC performed to date demonstrated SS+ results. The evidence was most robust regarding previously evaluated psychological support, especially mindfulness-based interventions (9/10 studies demonstrating SS+ improvement in primary outcomes), followed by therapeutically valid exercise with/without psychological support (5/8 RCTs demonstrated efficacy), then nutrition or pharmacological interventions (2/5 demonstrated efficacy). Level 1 evidence supports counselling patients and referral to mindfulness-based psychological therapy along with physical therapy or physical medicine and rehabilitation, as well as consideration of preoperative carbohydrate drinks. No studies have examined impact on caregivers, or cost-effectiveness, which are both critical areas for future study.
引用
- Briggs LG, Parke SC, Gill VS, et al. Exercise, nutrition, and psychological support for kidney cancer: a scoping review. BJU Int. 2026. PMID: 41549535. doi:10.1111/bju.70134
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。