指南与共识膀胱癌与上尿路尿路上皮癌

机器人辅助根治性肾输尿管切除术结构化培训课程:德尔菲共识研究

A structured training curriculum for robot-assisted radical nephroureterectomy: a Delphi consensus study.
指南 / 共识 · BJU Int · 2025-09-17

本研究通过两轮改良德尔菲法,邀请30名上尿路尿路上皮癌专家参与,旨在制定国际验证的机器人辅助根治性肾输尿管切除术(RARNU)结构化培训课程。第一轮和第二轮应答率分别为80%(24/30)和92%(22/24),所有拟议RARNU步骤的同意率≥92%,并定义了五个复杂度递增的临床模块(同意率≥96%)。专家一致认为最终评估应基于手术特异性量表,聚焦肾门分离、输尿管分离和膀胱袖状切除步骤,但未就年度最低手术量达成共识。

要点

  • 采用两轮改良德尔菲法,共识定义为≥80%同意。
  • 定义了五个复杂度递增的RARNU临床模块,同意率≥96%。
  • 最终评估应基于手术特异性量表,聚焦肾门、输尿管和膀胱袖状切除步骤。

核心结论

  • 这是首个通过国际专家共识制定的RARNU结构化培训课程,有助于指导外科教育者和学员独立完成完整RARNU。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用两轮改良德尔菲法,邀请30名上尿路尿路上皮癌专家参与,问卷涵盖五个关键领域和11个手术步骤。

主要发现

  • 第一轮和第二轮应答率分别为80%(24/30)和92%(22/24)。
  • 所有专家同意采用标准化培训课程可改善RARNU学习曲线中的临床结果。
  • 所有拟议RARNU步骤的同意率≥92%,五个临床模块的同意率≥96%。
  • 专家一致认为最终评估应基于手术特异性量表,聚焦肾门分离、输尿管分离和膀胱袖状切除步骤。
  • 未就RARNU课程主办中心的年度最低手术量达成共识。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识定义为≥80%同意。
  • 五个RARNU临床模块基于个体步骤难度和所需既往RARNU病例数定义,同意率≥96%。
  • 最终评估量表聚焦肾门分离、输尿管分离和膀胱袖状切除步骤。

临床怎么用

  • 该课程可用于指导外科教育者和学员结构化培训,以独立完成完整RARNU。
  • 最终评估应使用手术特异性量表,重点评估肾门分离、输尿管分离和膀胱袖状切除步骤。

局限性

  • 未就RARNU课程主办中心的年度最低手术量达成共识。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To develop an internationally validated, structured robot-assisted radical nephroureterectomy (RARNU) training programme through expert consensus. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A RARNU-specific questionnaire was developed/adapted from previously published, validated questionnaires for robot-assisted urological procedures. This included five key domains and 11 surgical steps. In all, 30 upper tract urothelial carcinoma experts were invited to participate. A two-stage modified Delphi approach was employed. Consensus was defined as ≥80% agreement. Modifications and additional statements were proposed during the second round following qualitative/quantitative feedback from the initial round. RESULTS: Response rates for the first and second Delphi rounds were 80% (24/30) and 92% (22/24), respectively. All agreed that adoption of a standardised training curriculum can improve clinical outcomes during the RARNU learning curve. There was ≥92% agreement on all proposed RARNU steps. Five RARNU clinical modules of increasing complexity were defined using individual step difficulty and number of prior RARNU cases required, with ≥96% agreement among respondents. Respondents unanimously agreed that the final assessment should be based on a procedure-specific scale focusing on the hilar dissection, ureteric dissection, and bladder cuff excision steps. No consensus was reached for the annual minimum RARNU volume required for eligibility as a RARNU curriculum host centre. CONCLUSION: This is the first structured training curriculum for RARNU using international expert consensus. This will help guide surgical educators and trainees toward independent completion of a full RARNU.

来源:BJU Int,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Moghaddam FS, Ghoreifi A, Sayyid RK, et al. A structured training curriculum for robot-assisted radical nephroureterectomy: a Delphi consensus study. BJU Int. 2025. PMID: 40960222. doi:10.1111/bju.70000

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。