前列腺癌共享决策讨论内容主题映射框架
研究转录50例局限性前列腺癌患者的多学科咨询,提取共享决策(SDM)相关引文并主题编码,构建SDM讨论内容框架。39例(78%)咨询涉及SDM,识别出决策过程描述(90%)、患者偏好与价值观(79%)和医生偏好(77%)三大主题,其中决策过程描述未纳入现行美国泌尿外科协会SDM指南。
要点
- 前列腺癌SDM咨询主要涵盖决策过程描述、患者偏好与价值观及医生偏好三大主题。
- 决策过程描述出现频率最高(90%),但现行AUA SDM指南未纳入该内容。
- 该主题映射框架可指导医生在前列腺癌SDM中系统覆盖关键讨论内容。
核心结论
- 主题映射框架概述了前列腺癌SDM咨询中的主要主题内容,可指导医生开展SDM讨论。
- 决策过程描述对确保患者理解其在SDM中的主动角色至关重要,应纳入未来AUA SDM指南更新。
研究设计与样本
- 转录50例局限性前列腺癌患者与多学科医生的咨询记录。
- 分析人员提取SDM相关引文,采用开放编码方法进行主题编码,并将共识主题汇总为更广泛类别。
- 计算咨询层面主题内容的频率。
主要发现
- 50例咨询中39例(78%)至少有一处与SDM相关的引文。
- 识别出三大主题内容领域:决策过程描述(35/39,90%)、患者偏好与价值观(31/39,79%)、医生偏好(30/39,77%)。
- 决策过程描述包含五个子内容领域:SDM总体描述、患者角色、医生角色、决策顺序及需避免的决策危害。
- SDM总体描述细分为:如何做决策(69%)、认可决策的共享性质(43%)、治疗决策的困难性(23%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 决策过程描述未纳入现行美国泌尿外科协会(AUA)SDM指南。
- 建议将决策过程描述纳入未来AUA SDM指南更新。
临床怎么用
- 医生可参考该主题映射框架指导前列腺癌SDM讨论,系统覆盖决策过程描述、患者偏好与价值观及医生偏好等内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To develop a framework for shared decision-making (SDM) in prostate cancer (PC) by identifying key topics that are covered during consultations. Although SDM is the guidelines-endorsed standard of care, there is no widely accepted standard for what to discuss during SDM. Previous data suggests content discussed during SDM is highly variable. METHODS: We transcribed consultations of 50 men with localized PC across multidisciplinary providers. Analysts extracted quotes related to SDM, thematically coded transcripts using an open coding approach, and aggregated consensus themes into broader categories. Frequency of thematic content at a consultation level was calculated. RESULTS: Of 50 consultations, 39 (78%) had at least one quote related to SDM. Three major thematic content areas were identified: description of the decision-making process (35/39, 90%), patient preferences and values (31/39, 79%), and physician preferences (30/39, 77%). Description of the decision-making process, not included in current American Urological Association SDM guidelines, included five sub-content areas: (1) general description of SDM, (2) patient role, (3) physician role, (4) decisions order, and (5) decision-making hazards to avoid. These sub-content areas were further subdivided into detailed areas of content discussed. For example, general description of SDM included describing how to make a decision (69%), endorsing the shared nature of decision making (43%), and the difficulty of treatment decisions (23%). CONCLUSION: Our topic-mapped framework outlines the major thematic content areas covered in PC SDM, which providers can use to guide SDM discussions with patients. Description of the decision-making process-which is critical to ensuring patients understand their active role in SDM-should be included in future iterations of American Urological Association SDM guidelines.
引用
- Friedrich NA, Kokorowski P, Luu M, et al. Topic Mapping to Inform Content to Discuss in Shared Decision-Making for Prostate Cancer. Urology. 2025. PMID: 40447161. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2025.05.053
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。