国际专家共识:用于尿道成形术及人工尿道括约肌植入术的男性会阴解剖模拟模型开发
11名专家完成模拟操作及问卷评估,多数认可模型在手术步骤、组织质地及解剖关系上的逼真度,认为其可作为尿道手术培训工具。
要点
- 专家共识达成的模拟模型可复现尿道暴露、组织质地及解剖关系。
- 模型在会阴切口/暴露、尿道游离、AUS泵放置等步骤获高认可度。
- 该高保真非生物危害模型有望弥补理论与实践的培训差距。
核心结论
- 利用专家共识成功设计出高保真、非生物危害的男性会阴尿道手术模拟模型,具有较高的手术与解剖逼真度,有潜力成为有效教育平台。
研究设计与样本
- 采用验证过的3D打印与水解胶模塑技术制作模型,原型发送给11名(58%)专家进行皮肤至皮肤的AUS及尿道成形术模拟。
- 通过尸体解剖与问卷评估模型是否达到共识定义的可交付成果,并确认手术过程中的解剖逼真度。
主要发现
- 总体而言,专家同意该模型可作为尿道手术的培训工具。
- 91%、82%和100%的专家分别同意模型在手术步骤上复现了完成尿道暴露所需的步骤、组织质地/行为以及整体解剖关系。
- 专家认可会阴切口/暴露(91%)、尿道游离/暴露(100%)、AUS泵放置(89%)、尿道袖带测量(100%)、尿道切开(91%)和尿道黏膜缝合(91%)的逼真度。
临床怎么用
- 该模型可用于尿道成形术和人工尿道括约肌植入术的培训,帮助学习者在安全环境中练习会阴区手术技能。
- 模型的高手术与解剖逼真度使其有潜力作为复杂尿道手术的教育平台, bridging the gap between theory and practice。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To create a high-fidelity, non-biohazardous, simulation model to train for urethroplasty or placement of artificial urinary sphincters (AUS) in the bulbar urethra. Narrow, deep and dark: the male perineum is a technically difficult area for learners to gain surgical skills and confidence. METHODS: Nineteen high volume reconstructive urologists were recruited to complete a Delphi process to reach an expert consensus on parameters and design specifications for simulation. Consensus (>80%) was reached regarding procedural realism, anatomical realism, and educational effectiveness. Using validated 3D printing and hydrogel molding techniques, we fabricated a model incorporating expert determined aspects. Prototypes were sent to 11 (58%) of the experts who performed skin-to-skin AUS and urethroplasty simulations. Autopsy and questionnaires evaluated the model to determine if the consensus-defined deliverables were met, and confirm the realism of anatomy during the procedures. RESULTS: Overall, experts agreed the model could function as a training tool for urethral surgery. 91%, 82%, and 100% agreed the model procedurally replicates the steps necessary to complete urethral exposure, tissue textures/behaviors, and overall anatomical relationships, respectively. Experts agreed on the fidelity of perineal incision/exposure (91%), urethral dissection/exposure (100%), placement of AUS pump (89%) urethral cuff measurement (100%) urethral spatulation (91%), and urethral mucosal suture placement (91%). CONCLUSION: We successfully designed a high-fidelity, non-biohazardous, simulation model for urethral procedures in the perineum utilizing expert consensus. The model displayed high procedural and anatomical realism, and has potential as an effective educational platform. This as a groundbreaking tool to enhance training in complex urethral surgeries, bridging the gap between theory and practice.
引用
- Cohen AJ, Saba P, Abalajon MT, et al. International Expert Consensus on Development of a State of the Art Male Perineal Anatomy Simulation Model for Urethroplasty and Artificial Urinary Sphincter Insertion. Urology. 2025. PMID: 40239927. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2025.03.054
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。