肾外伤管理:从「黑暗中摸索」到影像学革命的百年演变
本文通过广泛文献回顾及对专家 Jack McAninch 与 Jeremy B. Myers 的访谈,梳理过去100年肾外伤管理从保守观察、手术探查与肾切除术的争议,到CT和分级系统引入后以观察和避免干预为主的演变历程。
要点
- 肾外伤管理早期因评估和干预手段有限而以保守为主。
- 随着剖腹探查术确立,手术积极程度曾引发大量争议。
- 影像学技术进步尤其是CT及后续分级系统的引入深刻影响了肾外伤管理。
核心结论
- 过去一个世纪,泌尿外科医生从无影像、无临床共识的「黑暗中摸索」进步到利用高质量影像和循证指南管理肾外伤。
研究设计与样本
- 对档案材料和医学期刊文献(包括一手和二手文件)进行广泛文献回顾,主题为肾外伤管理及相关技术进步。
- 对包括 Jack McAninch 医生和 Jeremy B. Myers 医生在内的主题专家进行了主要对象访谈。
主要发现
- 肾外伤最早期的特点是保守主义,这主要是当时可用的评估和有效干预选项很少的结果。
- 随着手术技术发展和剖腹探查术作用确立,关于手术管理应有多积极存在相当多的争议。
- 与手术进展并行,影像技术的演变成为肾外伤管理中最具影响力的方面之一,最终以CT的引入及后续分级系统的出现为顶峰。
- 过去手术探查和肾切除术更常见,但实践已转向对大多数病例采取观察和避免干预。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To outline how practices have shifted over the past 100years while highlighting some of the key figures who have influenced the field. The management of renal trauma has long been an evolving and at times controversial field of study within urology. Though surgical exploration and nephrectomy were more common in the past, practice has shifted to observation and avoidance of intervention in most cases. Over the past century, technological advancements have given urologists and trauma surgeons the tools to improve clinical outcomes, which we outline in the following essay. METHODS: A broad literature review was performed of archival material and medical journal articles that included both primary and secondary documents related to renal trauma management and advances in relevant technology. Primary subject interviews were conducted with subject matter experts including Dr Jack McAninch and Dr Jeremy B. Myers. RESULTS: The earliest days of renal trauma were marked by conservatism that was largely a consequence of the few options available for evaluation and worthwhile intervention. As surgical techniques developed and the role of exploratory laparotomy became established, there was considerable debate over how aggressive surgical management should be. Alongside these operative advances, the evolution of radiographic techniques became one of the most impactful aspects in renal trauma management, culminating with the introduction of CT and subsequent grading scales. CONCLUSION: Over the past century, urologists have progressed from stabbing in the dark without imaging or clinical consensus, to managing renal trauma with high quality imaging and evidence-based guidelines.
引用
- Hacker EC, Noakes TC, McAninch JW, et al. Renal Trauma Management: A Century of Evolution From "Stabbing in the Dark" to the Radiographic Revolution. Urology. 2025. PMID: 40107460. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2025.02.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。