背侧覆盖与腹侧嵌入式颊黏膜移植尿道成形术治疗女性尿道狭窄的疗效比较:一项随机临床试验
这项在印度临床试验注册中心注册的随机临床试验比较了背侧覆盖(DO)与腹侧嵌入式(VI)颊黏膜移植尿道成形术(BMGU)治疗女性尿道狭窄(USD)的效果。2021年9月至2023年7月间,47例随机参与者中每组20例纳入最终分析,中位随访21个月。两组成功率均为95%,但VI-BMGU组手术时间更短、出血更少、疼痛评分更低且镇痛需求更少。
要点
- VI-BMGU与DO-BMGU治疗女性USD的成功率均为95%,每组各1例在1年随访时失败。
- VI-BMGU组中位出血量15 mL(10-15)vs DO-BMGU组10 mL(5-12.5),P=0.012,VI组更少。
- VI-BMGU组中位手术时间44.5分钟(40-52.5)vs DO-BMGU组30分钟(22-38),P<0.001,VI组更短。
核心结论
- VI-BMGU的结局与DO-BMGU相似,并具有手术时间更短、出血更少和疼痛更轻的额外优势。
研究设计与样本
- 这是一项在印度临床试验注册中心注册的随机临床试验,为女性尿道狭窄疾病领域的首个此类试验。
- 2021年9月至2023年7月间,女性USD患者接受DO-BMGU或VI-BMGU治疗。
- 47例随机参与者中,每组20例纳入最终分析;中位随访21个月,随访不足1年者被排除。
主要发现
- 每组各1例在1年随访时失败,两组成功率均为95%。
- VI-BMGU组中位出血量10 mL(5-12.5)vs DO-BMGU组15 mL(10-15),P=0.012,VI组出血更少。
- VI-BMGU组中位手术时间30分钟(22-38)vs DO-BMGU组44.5分钟(40-52.5),P<0.001,VI组手术时间更短。
- VI-BMGU组6小时和24小时中位视觉模拟量表评分显著更低(P<0.001),但48小时时无显著差异。
- VI-BMGU组镇痛需求更少(P<0.01)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为VI-BMGU的结局与DO-BMGU相似,并具有手术时间更短、出血更少和疼痛更轻的额外优势。
局限性
- 样本量小。
- 单机构经验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the outcomes of dorsal-onlay (DO) and ventral‑inlay (VI) buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty (BMGU). This is the first Clinical Trials Registry-India registered randomized clinical trial on female urethral stricture disease. METHODS: Women with USD underwent either DO-BMGU or VI-BMGU between September 2021 to July 2023. The primary objective was the success rates of the two techniques. The secondary objectives were duration of surgery, amount of blood loss, pain scores as assessed by Visual Analog Scale, and change in American Urological Association score, Qmax and postvoid residual. RESULTS: Of the 47 randomized participants, 20 patients in each group were taken up for final analysis. The median follow‑up period was 21months and those with less than 1year follow-up were excluded. One patient in each group had failure at 1year follow-up, giving a success rate of 95% in each arm. The median blood loss [15 mL (10-15) vs 10 mL (5-12.5), (P .012)] and median duration of surgery [44.5 minutes (40-52.5) vs 30 minutes (22-38), (P<.001)] were significantly less for VI-BMGU than for DO-BMGU. The median Visual Analog Scale scores at 6 and 24 hours were significantly lower (P<.001) for the VI-BMGU group but not at 48 hours. The VI-BMGU group required less analgesia (P<.01) as well. Small sample size and single institutional experience are limitations. CONCLUSION: The outcomes of VI-BMGU are similar to those of DO-BMGU, with the additional advantages of shorter operative time, lesser blood loss, and less pain.
引用
- Mandal S, Gaur AS, Singh K, et al. Comparative Efficacy of Dorsal-Onlay and Ventral-1 Inlay Buccal Mucosal Graft Urethroplasty in Female Urethral Stricture: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Urology. 2025. PMID: 39922235. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2025.01.064
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。