决策辅助工具实施方式在前列腺癌筛查中的效果:伞状综述与网络 Meta 分析
该伞状综述与网络 Meta 分析系统检索至 2023 年 8 月,纳入 7 篇系统综述,比较基于计算机、印刷、多媒体、视频和网站等决策辅助工具(DA)与常规护理在前列腺癌筛查决策结局中的效果。网络 Meta 分析显示,多媒体、印刷和网站式 DA 较计算机式 DA 显著提高共享决策参与率,计算机式 DA 组实际筛查利用率显著降低;网站式 DA 综合排名最高,其次为印刷式 DA。
要点
- 多媒体、印刷和网站式 DA 较计算机式 DA 显著提高共享决策参与率。
- 计算机式 DA 组实际筛查利用率较其他实施方式显著降低。
- 网站式 DA 在所有主要结局的综合排名最高,印刷式次之。
核心结论
- 不同类型的 DA 在提高知识水平、知识评分、共享决策参与和影响筛查行为方面效果不一;网站式 DA 似乎最有效,在资源有限的环境中采用印刷式 DA 可能是实用方案。
研究设计与样本
- 伞状综述与网络 Meta 分析,系统检索 PubMed、EMBASE、CINAHL、Google Advanced Search 和 TRIP 数据库自建库至 2023 年 8 月,纳入 7 篇系统综述,采用随机效应模型进行网络与成对 Meta 分析。
主要发现
- 网络 Meta 分析显示,多媒体(RR 1.51,95%CI 1.02-2.24)、印刷(RR 1.82,95%CI 1.23-2.69)和网站式(RR 1.99,95%CI 1.32-3.01)DA 较计算机式 DA 显著提高共享决策参与率。
- 计算机式 DA 组实际筛查利用率较其他实施方式显著降低;各实施方式在知识水平、知识评分、决策冲突、共享决策参与偏好和筛查意愿方面无显著差异。
- 所有主要结局的平均累积排名曲线下面积最高为网站式 DA,其次为印刷式 DA。
- 成对 Meta 分析显示,与常规护理相比,参与者知识水平和知识评分显著提高,筛查意愿和实际筛查利用率降低。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为网站式 DA 似乎最有效,在资源有限的环境中印刷式 DA 可能是实用方案。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To review and compare the efficacy of different delivery modes of decision aids (DAs), including computer-based, print-based, multimedia-based, video-based, and website-based on decision-making outcomes for prostate cancer screening compared to usual care (UC) and among the delivery modes. METHODS: PubMed, the Excerpta Medica dataBASE (EMBASE), Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), Google Advanced Search, and Turning Research Into Practice (TRIP) Database were systematically searched from inception to August 2023. The primary outcomes were knowledge level, knowledge scores, participation in shared decision-making (SDM), decisional conflict, and preference for SDM participation. Secondary outcomes were the proportion of subjects who underwent screening (actual screening utilisation) and the proportion of subjects who intended to be screened (intention to undergo screening). Network and pairwise meta-analyses were performed using random-effects models. RESULTS: Seven systematic reviews were included. Network meta-analysis found that multimedia (relative risk [RR] 1.51, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.02-2.24), print (RR 1.82, 95% CI 1.23-2.69), and website-based (RR 1.99, 95% CI 1.32-3.01) DAs significantly increased participation in SDM compared to the computer-based DA. There was a significant reduction in the actual screening utilisation in the computer DA arm compared to the other delivery modes. No significant differences between all delivery modes were noted on knowledge levels, knowledge scores, decisional conflict, preference for SDM participation, and intention to undergo screening. The highest mean surface under the cumulative ranking curve for all primary outcomes showed that website-based was the most effective delivery mode, followed by print-based DA. The pairwise meta-analysis showed a significant increase in participants' knowledge level, knowledge scores, a reduced intention to undergo screening and actual screening utilisation compared to UC. CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that different types of DAs have varying levels of effectiveness in increasing knowledge level, knowledge scores, participation in SDM, and influencing screening behaviours. While website-based DA appeared the most effective, employing the print-based DA could be a practical solution in settings with limited resources.
引用
- Ang ZY, Kong YL, Md Nesran ZN, et al. Efficacy of decision aid delivery modes in prostate cancer screening: umbrella review and network meta-analysis. BJU Int. 2024. PMID: 39402746. doi:10.1111/bju.16545
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。