尿道下裂重建培训:开发用于客观评估手术技能的离体模型
本研究在尿道下裂修复实操培训课程中,结合主观视频评估与客观肌电(EMG)测量,由18名不同经验水平的外科医生在离体小牛阴茎上完成4项操作。视频评估未显示短期培训的显著差异,但EMG测量显示培训后平均EMG功率、总时间、优势频率和累积肌肉工作量显著降低,平均功率谱密度也明显下降。
要点
- 离体小牛阴茎模型可用于尿道下裂修复的技能培训与评估。
- 视频评估未检出短期培训前后的显著差异。
- EMG测量显示培训后多项肌肉激活指标显著降低。
核心结论
- 本研究提出了尿道下裂培训的结构化方法,并表明可穿戴传感器技术可用于客观技能评估。
- 视频评估未检测到显著变化,而EMG数据提供了技能获取的可测量差异,提示可穿戴传感器可能增强住院医师项目中手术熟练度的客观评估。
研究设计与样本
- 在尿道下裂实操培训课程中,将主观视频评估与客观EMG测量相结合。
- 外科医生在优势手佩戴无线EMG和加速度传感器,在离体尸体小牛阴茎上完成操作。
- 研究聚焦4项技能:尿道游离、背侧嵌入移植物获取/植入、基于尿道口的皮瓣尿道成形术和背侧折叠术。
- 采用机器学习技术分析肌肉激活模式和属性以评估手术精确性。
- 课程纳入18名参与者(10名女性,8名男性;平均年龄40.18 ± 8.46岁),分为新手(n=10,经验<3年)、中级(n=5,3-5年)和专家(n=3,>5年)。
主要发现
- 视频评估未因短期培训而显示显著差异。
- EMG测量显示培训后平均EMG功率、总时间、优势频率和累积肌肉工作量显著降低。
- 培训后EMG信号的平均功率谱密度明显下降。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,可穿戴传感器可能增强住院医师项目中手术熟练度的客观评估。
局限性
- 视频评估未检测到显著变化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To objectively evaluate technical skill acquisition in hypospadias repair procedures during surgical training using noninvasive wearable sensor technology. METHODS: We combined subjective video evaluations with objective electromyography (EMG) measurements in a hands-on hypospadias training course. Surgeons wore wireless EMG and accelerometer sensors on their dominant hand while performing tasks on ex-vivo cadaveric calf penises. The study focused on 4 skills as follows: urethral mobilization, dorsal inlay graft harvest/implantation, meatal-based flap urethroplasty, and dorsal plication. Machine learning techniques analyzed muscle activation patterns and attributes for assessing surgical precision. RESULTS: The course included 18 participants (10 female, 8 males; average age 40.18 ± 8.46 years) categorized as novice (n = 10, <3 years' experience), intermediate (n = 5, 3-5 years), and expert (n = 3, >5 years). Video evaluations did not reveal significant differences due to short-term training. However, EMG measurements showed significant reductions in average EMG power, total time, dominant frequency, and cumulative muscle workload after training. Additionally, the mean power spectral density of the EMG signal decreased notably post-training. CONCLUSION: This study presents a structured approach for hypospadias training and highlights the effectiveness of wearable sensor technology for objective skill assessment. While video evaluations did not detect significant changes, EMG data provided measurable differences in skill acquisition, suggesting that wearable sensors could enhance objective evaluations of surgical proficiency in residency programs.
引用
- Abbas T, Tiryaki S, Tekin A, et al. Hypospadias Reconstruction Training: Development of an Ex-Vivo Model for Objective Evaluation of Surgical Skills. Urology. 2024. PMID: 39306302. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2024.09.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。