在肾脏模型中探索安全有效的铥光纤激光碎石术的最佳设置
本研究利用体外肾脏模型,在BegoStone假体和一水草酸钙结石上评估铥光纤激光碎石术的不同脉冲能量与频率组合。结果显示高脉冲能量/低频率设置(如0.8 J/12 Hz)相比0.2 J/50 Hz可提高治疗效率、减少残余碎片并缩短手术时间,且10 W功率下热损伤风险低于组织损伤阈值。
要点
- 高脉冲能量/低频率设置(0.8 J/12 Hz)在相同功率下治疗效率优于低脉冲能量/高频率设置。
- 0.8 J/12 Hz相比0.2 J/50 Hz,单位消融结石质量能耗降低39%,残余碎片减少35%,总手术时间缩短36%。
- 10 W功率的高脉冲能量/低频率组合热损伤风险低于组织损伤阈值,高于10 W则超过安全阈值。
核心结论
- 高脉冲能量/低频率设置(如0.8 J/12 Hz)是治疗一水草酸钙结石的铥光纤激光碎石术的最佳设置。
- 该设置相比常规设置显著提高治疗效率并减少残余碎片,同时将热剂量保持在损伤阈值以下。
- 使用低功率的高脉冲能量/低频率组合可最大化治疗效率并最小化潜在热损伤。
- 需要进一步研究以确定铥光纤激光治疗不同成分肾结石的最佳设置。
研究设计与样本
- 体外肾脏模型研究,在上肾盏评估铥光纤激光碎石术的疗效。
- 在BegoStone假体上进行结石消融实验,测试不同脉冲能量和频率组合以确定最佳设置。
- 使用嵌入热电偶监测温度变化和热损伤风险。
- 在一水草酸钙结石上验证最佳设置。
主要发现
- 相同功率下,高脉冲能量/低频率设置相比低脉冲能量/高频率设置表现出更优的治疗效率。
- 对于一水草酸钙结石,0.8 J/12 Hz相比0.2 J/50 Hz,治疗效率提高两倍,单位消融结石质量能耗降低39%,残余碎片减少35%,总手术时间缩短36%。
- 热损伤风险评估显示,10 W功率的高脉冲能量/低频率组合低于组织损伤阈值,而高于10 W的功率设置持续超过安全阈值。
局限性
- 需要进一步研究以确定铥光纤激光治疗不同成分肾结石的最佳设置。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To explore the optimal laser settings and treatment strategies for thulium fibre laser (TFL) lithotripsy, namely, those with the highest treatment efficiency, lowest thermal injury risk, and shortest procedure time. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An in vitro kidney model was used to assess the efficacy of TFL lithotripsy in the upper calyx. Stone ablation experiments were performed on BegoStone phantoms at different combinations of pulse energy (EP ) and frequency (F) to determine the optimal settings. Temperature changes and thermal injury risks were monitored using embedded thermocouples. Experiments were also performed on calcium oxalate monohydrate (COM) stones to validate the optimal settings. RESULTS: High EP /low F settings demonstrated superior treatment efficiency compared to low EP /high F settings using the same power. Specifically, 0.8 J/12 Hz was the optimal setting, resulting in a twofold increase in treatment efficiency, a 39% reduction in energy expenditure per unit of ablated stone mass, a 35% reduction in residual fragments, and a 36% reduction in total procedure time compared to the 0.2 J/50 Hz setting for COM stones. Thermal injury risk assessment indicated that 10 W power settings with high EP /low F combinations remained below the threshold for tissue injury, while higher power settings (>10 W) consistently exceeded the safety threshold. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that high EP /low F settings, such as 0.8 J/12 Hz, are optimal for TFL lithotripsy in the treatment of COM stones. These settings demonstrated significantly improved treatment efficiency with reduced residual fragments compared to conventional settings while keeping the thermal dose below the injury threshold. This study highlights the importance of using the high EP /low F combination with low power settings, which maximizes treatment efficiency and minimizes potential thermal injury. Further studies are warranted to determine the optimal settings for TFL for treating kidney stones with different compositions.
引用
- Mishra A, Medairos R, Chen J, et al. Exploring optimal settings for safe and effective thulium fibre laser lithotripsy in a kidney model. BJU Int. 2023. PMID: 37942684. doi:10.1111/bju.16218
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。