指南与共识

推荐信中的性别偏见:与泌尿外科匹配结果及追求专科培训或学术职业的相关性

Gender Bias in Letters of Recommendation: Relevance to Urology Match Outcomes and Pursuit of Fellowship Training/Academic Career.
指南 / 共识 · Urology · 2023-11-07

该研究回顾了单一家泌尿外科住院医师项目的222份2014年周期申请,分析23个变量,包括申请者人口学、申请材料和性别偏见,以确定预测成功匹配泌尿外科住院医师以及住院医师完成后追求专科培训或学术执业的申请特征,主要关注变量为推荐信、个人陈述、医学生表现评估中的性别偏见、种族和性别。首次作者发表的论文与更高的匹配几率显著相关,女性和前25名医学院就读均是匹配到前25名泌尿外科项目的显著预测因素,第一作者论文数量与完成专科培训或目前受雇于学术职位相关。申请材料中的性别偏见似乎未对匹配和早期职业结果产生显著影响。

要点

  • 首次作者发表的论文是匹配成功及后续追求学术执业或专科培训的最重要面试前决定因素
  • 女性和前25名医学院就读是匹配到前25名泌尿外科项目的显著预测因素
  • 申请材料中的性别偏见似乎未对匹配和早期职业结果产生显著影响

核心结论

  • 首次作者发表的论文是匹配成功及后续追求学术执业或专科培训的最重要面试前决定因素
  • 某些申请者特征与匹配到高排名项目相关
  • 申请材料(包括推荐信)中的性别偏见似乎未对匹配和早期职业结果产生显著影响

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析单一家泌尿外科住院医师项目2014年周期提交的222份完整申请
  • 分析23个变量,包括申请者人口学、申请材料和性别偏见
  • 使用开源性别偏见计算器评估推荐信、个人陈述和医学生表现评估的去标识文本中的性别偏见
  • 对匹配到前25名泌尿外科项目的申请者进行亚组分析
  • 采用逻辑回归分析识别与匹配成功以及截至2021年9月完成专科培训或学术就业相关的申请者变量

主要发现

  • 首次作者发表的论文与更高的匹配几率显著相关
  • 女性和前25名医学院就读均是匹配到前25名泌尿外科项目的显著预测因素
  • 第一作者论文数量与完成专科培训或目前受雇于学术职位相关

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To review applications to a single urology residency program to determine application characteristics predictive of (1) successful match into urology residency and (2) pursuit of fellowship training and/or academic practice after completion of residency. Our principal variables of interest were gender bias as assessed in letters of recommendation (LOR), personal statements, Medical Student Performance Evaluation (MSPE), race, and gender. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Applications submitted to our urology residency program in the 2014 cycle were reviewed. Twenty-three variables were analyzed, including applicant demographics, application materials, and gender bias. Deidentified text from LOR, personal statements, and MSPE was evaluated for gender bias using an open-source gender bias calculator. A subanalysis of applicants who matched at a top 25 urology program was performed. Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify applicant variables associated with (1) match success and (2) fellowship training or academic employment as of September 2021. RESULTS: Two hundred and twenty-two completed applications were analyzed. First authorship of a published manuscript was significantly associated with greater odds of matching. Female gender and top 25 medical school attendance were both significant predictors of matching at a top 25 urology program. The number of first-author publications was associated with completion of fellowship training or current employment in an academic position. CONCLUSION: First-author publications are the most important preinterview determinant of match success and subsequent pursuit of academic practice/fellowship training. Certain applicant characteristics are associated with matching at highly ranked programs. Gender bias in application materials (including LOR) does not appear to exert a significant influence on match and early career outcomes.

来源:Urology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nosrat C, Martin-Tuite P, Jiang F, et al. Gender Bias in Letters of Recommendation: Relevance to Urology Match Outcomes and Pursuit of Fellowship Training/Academic Career. Urology. 2023. PMID: 37940078. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2023.09.053

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。