肾结石疾病比较效果研究的系统性范围综述
该系统性范围综述检索2005年1月1日至2021年3月30日发表的肾结石比较效果研究,纳入1773篇摘要和707篇全文,聚焦手术干预、药物排石治疗、镇痛控制及顺势疗法、诊断和预防等主题。随机对照试验在各结局类别中常见,患者报告结局在药物排石和镇痛控制研究中应用较多,Meta分析和多中心研究随时间增加(P < .001)。
要点
- 手术干预和药物排石治疗主题占 published 比较文献的主导地位。
- 随机对照试验在手术(41.6%)、药物排石(60.2%)、镇痛控制(81.3%)等类别中常见。
- 患者报告结局在药物排石(71.7%)和镇痛控制(95%)研究中应用较多,其他主题较少。
核心结论
- 手术和药物排石治疗主题主导肾结石疾病的已发表比较文献。
- 患者报告结局在不同手术主题中的使用存在显著差异。
- 多中心研究和产生更高等级证据的研究随时间增加,但在肾结石疾病中改善协作、高质量和以患者为中心的研究仍存在机会。
研究设计与样本
- 系统性范围综述,检索2005年1月1日至2021年3月30日发表的英文文献。
- 纳入比较两种或以上预防、诊断、治疗、监测或照护提供替代方法的研究。
- 两名评审员独立审阅摘要,分歧由仲裁者解决;九名评审员从全文研究中提取信息。
- 共审阅1773篇摘要和707篇全文手稿。
主要发现
- 707篇全文手稿聚焦于手术干预(440篇)、药物排石治疗(MET)(152篇)、镇痛控制(80篇)以及顺势疗法、诊断和/或预防(84篇)。
- 随机对照试验在手术(41.6%)、MET(60.2%)、镇痛控制(81.3%)、顺势疗法(41.2%)、诊断(47.6%)和预防(49.1%)类别中常见。
- 患者报告结局在MET研究的71.7%和镇痛控制研究的95%中被使用,但在所有其他研究主题中占少数。
- 随时间推移,Meta分析和多中心研究增加(P < .001)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To review the status of comparative effectiveness studies for kidney stone disease with focus on study outcome, type, population, time trends, and patient-centered approaches. METHODS: A systematic scoping review was performed for articles published between January 1, 2005, and March 30, 2021, using keywords relevant to kidney stone disease. Studies published in English that compared two or more alternative methods for prevention, diagnosis, treatment, monitoring, or care delivery were included. Two reviewers independently reviewed abstracts and an arbitrator resolved discrepancies. Nine reviewers abstracted information from full-length studies. Descriptive statistics were summarized, and linear regression was performed to evaluate temporal trends of study characteristics. RESULTS: We reviewed 1773 abstracts and 707 full-length manuscripts focused on surgical intervention (440); medical expulsive therapy (MET) (152); analgesic control (80); and homeopathic, diagnostics, and/or prophylaxis (84). Randomized controlled trials were common across all outcome categories, including surgery (41.6%), MET (60.2%), analgesic control (81.3%), homeopathic (41.2%), diagnostic (47.6%), and prophylaxis (49.1%). Patient-reported outcomes were utilized in 71.7% and 95% of MET and analgesic control studies, respectively, but in the minority of all other study themes. Over time, meta-analyses and multicenter studies increased [P < .001]. CONCLUSION: Surgical and MET themes dominate published comparative literature in kidney stone disease. There is substantial variation in use of patient-reported outcomes across surgical themes. Multicentered studies and those generating higher level evidence have increased over time but opportunities exist to improve collaborative, high-quality, and patient-centered research in kidney stone disease.
引用
- Dangle P, Tasian GE, Chu DI, et al. A Systematic Scoping Review of Comparative Effectiveness Studies in Kidney Stone Disease. Urology. 2023. PMID: 37806455. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2023.08.042
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。