基于计算机断层扫描的高效准确结石体积测定:自动化人工智能算法的开发
本研究回顾性纳入322例非增强CT的尿路结石患者,以3D Slicer测定的最大结石体积为金标准,比较加州大学欧文分校开发的人工智能(AI)算法与三种椭球公式及最大径线的准确性。AI体积与金标准近乎完美相关(R=0.98),Dice评分0.90,优于椭球公式(R=0.79-0.82)和最大径线(R=0.41-0.82)。
要点
- AI测定的结石体积与金标准体积高度相关(R=0.98),三维像素重叠Dice评分为0.90。
- 椭球公式体积与金标准的相关性为R=0.79-0.82,且随结石增大准确性下降,平均高估27%-89%。
- 最大线性径线与金标准的相关性最差(R=0.41-0.82)。
核心结论
- 加州大学欧文分校的AI算法是测定结石体积的准确、精确且省时的工具。
- 扩大该程序的临床可及性可能使泌尿外科医生能够为尿路结石患者的代谢和手术治疗制定更好的指南。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性获取322例诊断为尿路结石患者的非增强CT扫描。
- 每例非增强CT扫描中最大的结石被指定为「索引结石」。
- 由经过验证的审查者使用3D Slicer技术测定索引结石的三维体积,作为「金标准」体积。
- 将AI计算的索引结石体积与金标准体积以及不等边、长球、扁球椭球公式估算体积进行比较。
主要发现
- AI测定的体积与金标准之间近乎完美相关(R=0.98)。
- AI算法对所有大小的结石均能高效测定体积,且准确性随结石尺寸增大而提高。
- AI结石体积与金标准产生极好的三维像素重叠(Dice评分=0.90)。
- 椭球公式基于的体积表现不如AI算法(R范围:0.79-0.82),且椭球公式的准确性随结石尺寸增大而下降(平均高估27%-89%)。
- 对于所有结石尺寸,最大线性结石测量与金标准的相关性最差(R范围:0.41-0.82)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出,扩大该程序的临床可及性可能使泌尿外科医生能够为尿路结石患者的代谢和手术治疗制定更好的指南。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Given the shortcomings of current stone burden characterization (maximum diameter or ellipsoid formulas), we sought to investigate the diagnostic accuracy and precision of a University of California, Irvine-developed artificial intelligence (AI) algorithm for determining stone volume determination. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 322 noncontrast CT scans were retrospectively obtained from patients with a diagnosis of urolithiasis. The largest stone in each noncontrast CT scan was designated the "index stone." The 3D volume of the index stone using 3D Slicer technology was determined by a validated reviewer; this was considered the "ground truth" volume. The AI-calculated index stone volume was subsequently compared with ground truth volume as well with the scalene, prolate, and oblate ellipsoid formulas estimated volumes. RESULTS: There was a nearly perfect correlation between the AI-determined volume and the ground truth (R=0.98). While the AI algorithm was efficient for determining the stone volume for all sizes, its accuracy improved with larger stone size. Moreover, the AI stone volume produced an excellent 3D pixel overlap with the ground truth (Dice score=0.90). In comparison, the ellipsoid formula-based volumes performed less well (R range: 0.79-0.82) than the AI algorithm; for the ellipsoid formulas, the accuracy decreased as the stone size increased (mean overestimation: 27%-89%). Lastly, for all stone sizes, the maximum linear stone measurement had the poorest correlation with the ground truth (R range: 0.41-0.82). CONCLUSIONS: The University of California, Irvine AI algorithm is an accurate, precise, and time-efficient tool for determining stone volume. Expanding the clinical availability of this program could enable urologists to establish better guidelines for both the metabolic and surgical management of their urolithiasis patients.
引用
- Cumpanas AD, Chantaduly C, Morgan KL, et al. Efficient and Accurate Computed Tomography-Based Stone Volume Determination: Development of an Automated Artificial Intelligence Algorithm. J Urol. 2023. PMID: 37889957. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000003766
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。