肾外伤后的碎裂肾:是否应归类为美国创伤外科协会V级损伤
本研究利用2013至2018年21家一级创伤中心的高级别肾外伤数据,分析碎裂肾的患病率与处理方式,并评估2018年美国创伤外科协会器官损伤量表新增的「可识别肾解剖结构丧失」描述能否改善对出血控制干预的预测能力。
要点
- 861例高级别肾外伤中41例(4.8%)为碎裂肾,25例(61%)接受出血控制干预。
- 碎裂肾合并血管对比剂外溢(VCE)模型预测出血干预的曲线下面积优于「可识别肾解剖结构丧失」模型(0.75 vs 0.72;P = .01)。
- 2018年AAST器官损伤量表中「可识别肾解剖结构丧失」定义对出血控制干预的区分能力未优于VCE的存在。
核心结论
- 碎裂肾与活动性出血、尿外渗及包括肾切除术在内的干预高发生率相关。
- 碎裂肾的定义模糊且主观,本研究提出的定义可能更简单且可重复性更好。
- 2018年AAST器官损伤量表中「可识别肾解剖结构丧失」对出血控制干预的区分能力未优于血管对比剂外溢的存在。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用2013至2018年21家一级创伤中心的高级别肾外伤数据。
- 通过初始CT扫描识别碎裂肾,定义为横断面影像上肾脏有≥3个被血液或液体推移的实质碎片。
- 将碎裂肾患者按「可识别肾实质解剖结构丧失」和「血管对比剂外溢(VCE)存在与否」分为两种模型进行比较。
主要发现
- 861例高级别肾外伤患者中41例(4.8%)存在碎裂肾损伤。
- 41例碎裂肾患者中25例(61%)接受出血控制干预,包括18例(43.9%)肾切除术和11例(26.8%)血管栓塞术。
- 18例(41%)按2018年AAST器官损伤量表存在「可识别肾实质解剖结构丧失」(模型1)。
- 28例(68.3%)合并血管对比剂外溢(模型2)。
- 模型2预测出血干预的曲线下面积较模型1有统计学显著改善(0.75 vs 0.72;P = .01)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To study the prevalence and management of shattered kidney and to evaluate if the new description of "loss of identifiable renal anatomy" in the 2018 American Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST) organ injury scale (OIS) would improve the ability to predict bleeding control interventions. METHODS: We used high-grade renal trauma data from 21 Level-1 trauma centers from 2013 to 2018. Initial CT scans were reviewed to identify shattered kidneys, defined as a kidney having ≥3 parenchymal fragments displaced by blood or fluid on cross-sectional imaging. We further categorized patients with shattered kidney in two models based on loss of identifiable renal parenchymal anatomy and presence or absence of vascular contrast extravasation (VCE). Bleeding interventions were compared between the groups. RESULTS: From 861 high-grade renal trauma patients, 41 (4.8%) had shattered kidney injury. 25 (61%) underwent a bleeding control intervention including 18 (43.9%) nephrectomies and 11 (26.8%) angioembolizations. 18 (41%) had shattered kidney with "loss of identifiable parenchymal renal anatomy" per 2018 AAST OIS (model-1). 28 (68.3%) had concurrent VCE (model-2). Model-2 had a statistically significant improvement in area under the curve over model-1 in predicting bleeding interventions (0.75 vs 0.72; P = .01). CONCLUSION: Shattered kidney is associated with high rates of active bleeding, urinary extravasation, and interventions including nephrectomy. The definition of shattered kidney is vague and subjective and our definition might be simpler and more reproducible. Loss of identifiable renal anatomy per the 2018 AAST OIS did not provide better distinction for bleeding control interventions over presence of VCE.
引用
- Keihani S, Rogers DM, Wang SS, et al. Shattered Kidney After Renal Trauma: Should It Be Classified As an American Association for the Surgery of Trauma Grade V Injury? Urology. 2023. PMID: 37356461. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2023.06.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。