三维打印技术用于创建高保真输尿管镜模拟器:开发与有效性评估(Rein-3D-Print-UroCCR-39)
本研究基于真实病例的CT扫描构建三维打印柔性输尿管镜模拟器,19名参与者(6名医学生、7名住院医师、6名泌尿外科fellow)间隔1个月完成两次模拟手术。两次评估间总体评分(29.4 vs 21.9分,满分35,P<.001)、任务特异性评分(17.7 vs 14.7分,满分20,P<.001)及手术时间(498.5 vs 700秒,P=.001)均显著改善,医学生进步最大。
要点
- 三维打印输尿管镜模拟器可提升内镜初学者的操作表现。
- 19名参与者两次评估间总体评分与任务特异性评分均显著提高。
- 69.2%参与者认为模型视觉上相当或高度逼真,全部认为对实习培训有趣。
核心结论
- 三维打印输尿管镜模拟器能促进内镜初学者的进步,且有效且价格合理,可能成为泌尿外科培训项目的一部分,符合最新外科教育建议。
研究设计与样本
- 基于真实病例CT扫描分割构建含膀胱、输尿管和肾腔的三维模型并打印,置入肾结石,模拟手术为整块结石取出。
- 19名参与者按水平分为3组:6名医学生、7名住院医师、6名泌尿外科fellow,间隔1个月完成两次操作。
- 基于匿名计时视频录像进行总体评分和任务特异性评分。
主要发现
- 两次评估间总体评分29.4 vs 21.9分(满分35),P<.001。
- 两次评估间任务特异性评分17.7 vs 14.7分(满分20),P<.001。
- 两次评估间手术时间498.5 vs 700秒,P=.001。
- 医学生总体评分进步最大(平均+15.5分,P=.001),任务特异性评分进步最大(平均+6.5分,P<.001)。
- 69.2%参与者认为模型视觉上相当逼真或高度逼真,全部参与者认为对实习培训相当或极其有趣。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该三维打印输尿管镜模拟器可能成为泌尿外科培训项目的一部分,符合最新外科教育建议。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To create and assess the validity of a high-fidelity, three dimensional (3D) printed, flexible ureteroscopy simulator resulting from a real case. METHODS: A patient's CT scan was segmented to obtain a 3D model in .stl format, including the urinary bladder, ureter and renal cavities. The file was printed and a kidney stone was introduced into the cavities. The simulated surgery consisted of monobloc stone extraction. Nineteen participants split into 3 groups according to their level (6 medical students, 7 residents and 6 urology fellows) performed the procedure twice at a 1-month interval. They were rated according to a global score and a task-specific score, based on an anonymized, timed video recording. RESULTS: Participants demonstrated a significant improvement between the 2 assessments, both on the global score (29.4 vs 21.9 points out of 35; P < .001) and the task-specific score (17.7 vs 14.7 points out of 20; P < .001) as well as procedure time (498.5 vs 700 seconds; P = .001). Medical students showed the greatest progress for the global score (+15.5 points (mean), P = .001) and the task-specific score (+6.5 points (mean), P < .001). 69.2% of participants considered the model as visually quite realistic or highly realistic and all of them judged it quite or extremely interesting for intern training purposes. CONCLUSION: Our 3D printed ureteroscopy simulator was able to enhance the progress of medical students who are new to endoscopy, whilst being valid and reasonably priced. It could become part of a training program in urology, in line with the latest recommendations for surgical education.
引用
- Boulenger de Hauteclocque A, Michiels C, Sarrazin J, et al. Three Dimensional Printing Technology Used to Create a High-Fidelity Ureteroscopy Simulator: Development and Validity Assessment (Rein-3D-Print-UroCCR-39). Urology. 2023. PMID: 36907468. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2023.02.039
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。