对直接面向消费者的男性健康诊所的在线调查:对象、内容与地点
本研究通过互联网检索美国各州直接面向消费者(DTC)的男性健康诊所,共回顾223家独立诊所的在线内容。结果显示,147家(65.9%)提供勃起功能障碍(ED)治疗,196家(87.9%)提供睾酮替代治疗,120家(53.8%)同时提供两者;提供ED治疗的诊所中,93家(63.3%)宣传冲击波治疗,84家(57.1%)宣传富血小板血浆(PRP)治疗。结论认为男性健康领域存在显著异质性和错误信息,熟悉这些诊所的实践模式有助于提供知情患者护理和咨询。
要点
- 223家DTC男性健康诊所中,87.9%提供睾酮替代,65.9%提供ED治疗,53.8%同时提供两者。
- 提供ED治疗的诊所中,63.3%宣传冲击波治疗,57.1%宣传PRP治疗;38%同时提供两者。
- 有泌尿科医生在职时更可能提供ICI(p<.001);20.1%诊所未列出提供者。
核心结论
- 男性健康领域面向公众存在显著异质性和错误信息,熟悉DTC男性健康诊所的实践模式有助于提供知情患者护理和咨询。
研究设计与样本
- 通过互联网按州检索美国DTC男性健康诊所,检索词为「Men's Health Clinic」和「Low T Center」,回顾所有独立诊所的在线内容,共纳入223家诊所。
主要发现
- 223家诊所中,147家(65.9%)提供ED治疗,196家(87.9%)提供睾酮替代治疗,120家(53.8%)同时提供两者。
- 提供ED治疗的诊所中,93家(63.3%)宣传冲击波治疗,84家(57.1%)宣传PRP治疗,56家(38%)同时提供冲击波和PRP治疗。
- 有泌尿科医生在职时更可能提供ICI(p<.001)。
- 诊所提供者涵盖20种医学和替代医学专科,内科最常见(17.4%),其次为家庭医学(11.1%)。
- 非医师(执业护士或医师助理)被列为10家诊所(4.5%)的主要提供者,45家诊所(20.1%)未列出提供者,泌尿科医生被列为10.3%诊所的主要提供者,22家诊所(11.6%)列出自然疗法提供者为工作人员。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To characterize direct-to-consumer (DTC) men's health clinics by reviewing their online content. Increasing numbers of patients are seeking treatment for erectile dysfunction (ED) and hypogonadism from DTC "men's health" clinics. Treatments are often used off-label, with lack of transparency of provider credentials and qualifications. METHODS: We identified DTC Men's Health Clinics in the United States by internet search by state using the terms, "Men's Health Clinic," and "Low T Center." All stand-alone clinics were reviewed. RESULTS: Two hundred and twenty-three clinics were reviewed, with 147 (65.9%) offered ED treatments and 196 (87.9%) offering testosterone replacement, and 120 (53.8%) offering both ED treatment and testosterone replacement. Of those clinics offering ED treatments, 93 (63.3%) advertised shockwave therapy and 84 (57.1%) PRP therapy. There were 56 (38%) who offered shockwave therapy and PRP. ICI was significantly more likely to be offered if there was a urologist on staff (p <.001). Clinic providers represented 20 different medical and alternative medicine specialties. Internal medicine was most common (17.4%), followed by family medicine (11.1%). A nonphysician (nurse practitioner or physician assistant) was listed as the primary provider in 10 clinics (4.5%) and 45 clinics (20.1%) did not list their providers. Urologists were listed as the primary provider in 10.3% of clinics. A naturopathic provider was listed as a staff member in 22 (11.6%) of clinics. CONCLUSION: There is significant heterogeneity and misinformation available to the public regarding men's health. Familiarity with and insight into practice patterns of "men's health" clinics will help provide informed patient care and counseling.
引用
- Dietrich PN, Doolittle J, Brink S, et al. An Online Investigation Into Direct-to-Consumer Men's Health Clinics: The Who, What, and Where. Urology. 2023. PMID: 36736913. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2023.01.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。