不合指南的勃起功能障碍研究性治疗:患者在YouTube上能学到什么
本研究评估YouTube上关于冲击波、富血小板血浆和干细胞治疗勃起功能障碍(ED)内容的可靠性。共纳入71个视频,平均DISCERN评分仅42.8/80,仅3个视频提及这些疗法的研究性/实验性状态,仅2个引用学会指南。大多数视频不可靠且来自非泌尿科医生,可能误导患者以高额费用寻求这些仍处于研究阶段的治疗。
要点
- YouTube上关于再生性ED治疗的视频大多不可靠,平均DISCERN评分仅42.8/80。
- 仅3个视频提及疗法的研究性/实验性状态,仅2个引用学会指南。
- 由泌尿科医生参与的视频质量更高且更可能基于指南。
核心结论
- 大多数关于再生性ED治疗的YouTube视频不可靠且来自非泌尿科医生,对疗效的误导性描述可能鼓励患者以高额费用寻求这些仍处于研究阶段的治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 在YouTube以「shockwave therapy」「platelet-rich plasma」「stem cell therapy」联合「for erectile dysfunction」检索,每个查询筛选前50个视频,纳入标准为标题/内容相关、英语、观看次数>100,由2名独立评分者使用经过验证的DISCERN消费者健康信息量表评判,并进行回归分析评估视频特征与DISCERN评分的关联。
主要发现
- 共71个独特视频符合标准;非医生内容占37%,非泌尿科医生内容占35%,泌尿科医生内容占28%。
- 平均DISCERN评分为42.8/80,评分较低。
- DISCERN评分随视频类别和特征显著不同:教育类和泌尿科医生参与的视频与更高评分相关,新闻报道与更低评分相关。
- 仅3个视频提及这些疗法的研究性/实验性状态,仅2个引用学会指南。
关键数值与推荐
- 原文未报告
临床怎么用
- 作者认为泌尿外科和学术社区应继续利用社交媒体的力量,在该领域提供有证据支持的消费者健康信息。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the validity of YouTube content on shockwave, platelet-rich plasma, and stem cell therapies for erectile dysfunction (ED). The consumerization of men's health is particularly notable among regenerative ED treatments, and the popularity of these treatments has been amplified by social media sites such as YouTube. METHODS: We searched YouTube utilizing the following terms: "shockwave therapy-," "platelet-rich plasma- and "stem cell therapy-" "-for erectile dysfunction." The first 50 resulting videos per query were screened (inclusion criteria: relevant title/content, English language, >100 views) and judged by 2 independent graders using the validated DISCERN instrument for consumer health information. Regression analysis assessed association of video characteristics with DISCERN score. RESULTS: Seventy-one unique videos met criteria. More content featured non-physicians (37%) or non-urologist physicians (35%) than urologists (28%). Mean DISCERN score was low at 42.8 of 80. DISCERN score significantly differed by video category and characteristics. Educational and urologist-featuring videos were associated with higher score. News reports were associated with lower score. Only 3 videos mentioned investigational/experimental status of the therapies. Only 2 cited society guidelines. CONCLUSION: Most YouTube videos on regenerative ED therapies are unreliable and from non-urologists. The misrepresentation of proven efficacy may be encouraging patients to seek these still investigational treatments at high fiscal costs to the patient. Videos with urologists were more likely to be higher quality and guideline based. The urological and academic communities should continue to leverage the power of social media to provide evidence-backed consumer health information in this space.
引用
- Hu MY, Ho DR, Weinberger JM, et al. Guideline-Nonconformant Investigational Treatments for Erectile Dysfunction: What are Patients Learning? Urology. 2022. PMID: 36584789. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2022.11.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。