柔性输尿管镜断裂成本:数码与光纤模式对比
该研究比较了数码柔性输尿管镜(DFU)与光纤柔性输尿管镜(FFU)的维护成本,分析了2019至2021年一家学术机构的断裂数据。共完成2154例f-URS,其中FFU 1355例、DFU 799例(P<.001)。FFU断裂事件数(124次)高于DFU(73次)(P<.001),但总体断裂率相似(9.9% vs 8.8%,P=0.86)。累积分析显示,两种模式在18个月后达到相同的无故障手术数平台(11例)。400例后,DFU的每例修复成本是FFU的1.25倍(P=0.04)。结论认为两种镜子总体断裂率无差异,DFU初期耐用性更高导致RCpP较低,但随时间推移DFU耐用性降至与FFU相当,导致400例后RCpP更高。
要点
- FFU断裂事件数124次高于DFU 73次(P<.001),但总体断裂率9.9% vs 8.8%无显著差异(P=0.86)。
- 累积分析中两种模式在18个月后达到相同的无故障手术数平台(11例)。
- 400例后DFU的每例修复成本是FFU的1.25倍(P=0.04)。
核心结论
- DFU与FFU的总体镜子断裂率无差异;DFU初期耐用性更高使RCpP较低,但随时间推移DFU耐用性降至与FFU相当,导致400例后RCpP更高。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为在学术机构开展的对比分析,数据来自供应商(Karl Storz),覆盖2019年至2021年,按月分析FFU与DFU的断裂情况。
主要发现
- 共完成2154例f-URS,其中FFU 1355例、DFU 799例(P<.001)。
- FFU断裂事件数124次高于DFU 73次(P<.001),但总体断裂率9.9% vs 8.8%无显著差异(P=0.86)。
- 累积分析中两种模式在18个月后达到相同的无故障手术数平台(11例)。
- 400例后DFU的每例修复成本是FFU的1.25倍(P=0.04)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the maintenance costs of digital flexible ureteroscopes (DFU) versus fiberoptic flexible ureteroscopes (FFU) to understand the long-term financial impact associated with breakage in a flexible ureteroscopy (f-URS) program. METHODS: Data for breakage of FFU and DFU at an academic institution from 2019 to 2021 were obtained from our vendor (Karl Storz) and analyzed by month. Correlation test was used to evaluate significant differences in number of procedures, number of breakage events, breakage rates, and repair cost per month. Cumulative analyses were utilized to examine the number of procedures before failure (time to failure - TTF) and repair costs per procedure (RCpP). RESULTS: We performed a total of 2,154 f-URS, including 1,355 with FFU and 799 with DFU (P<.001). Although we found a higher number of breakage events in FFU (n=124) than DFU (n=73) (P<.001), the overall breakage rate was similar, 9.9% vs. 8.8%, respectively (P=0.86). On cumulative analysis, both modalities reached the same TTF plateau (11 cases) after 18 months. After 400 cases, the RCpP for DFU was 1.25 times higher than for FFU (P=0.04). CONCLUSION: Overall, we found no difference in overall scope breakage rates between DFU and FFU. Although there was no difference in TTF over time, at the beginning DFU displayed considerable higher durability, leading to lower RCpP. Furthermore, DFU's endurance leveled off to FFU over time, resulting in higher RCpP after 400 cases. This finding may be explained by the presence of renewed scopes after repair.
引用
- Ito WE, Igel DA, Whiles BB, et al. Breakage Costs in Flexible Ureteroscopy: Digital vs. Fiberoptic Modalities. Urology. 2022. PMID: 36400269. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2022.10.027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。