铥光纤激光与钬:钇铝石榴石激光碎石术治疗尿路结石的临床研究Meta分析
该Meta分析比较铥光纤激光(TFL)与钬:钇铝石榴石(Ho:YAG)激光内镜碎石治疗尿路结石的临床结局,纳入15项研究共1698例。总体无结石率两组无显著差异(RR 1.09,95%CI 0.99-1.20),但TFL对比无脉冲调制的Ho:YAG时无结石率更优(RR 1.11,95%CI 1.01-1.23)。TFL的手术时间和激光使用时间更短、消融率更优,无脉冲调制Ho:YAG的逆向推动程度更低,并发症率、消融效率、总能量使用和住院时间两组相当,证据确定性为极低。
要点
- 总体无结石率TFL与Ho:YAG无显著差异(RR 1.09,95%CI 0.99-1.20)。
- TFL对比无脉冲调制Ho:YAG时无结石率更优(RR 1.11,95%CI 1.01-1.23)。
- TFL手术时间和激光使用时间更短、消融率更优,并发症率等相当。
核心结论
- 总体无结石率两组无显著差异,但TFL对比无脉冲调制Ho:YAG时无结石率更优。
- TFL的手术时间和激光使用时间更短、逆向推动程度更低、消融率更优。
- 并发症率、消融效率、总能量使用和住院时间两组相当,现有临床证据确定性极低。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索于2022年5月进行,灰色文献检索于2022年7月进行。
- 纳入比较TFL与Ho:YAG激光内镜碎石治疗尿路结石的临床研究,共15项研究1698例。
- 按Cochrane推荐评估,行亚组分析、异质性、发表偏倚和GRADE评估,PROSPERO注册号CRD42022300788。
主要发现
- 总体无结石率两组无显著差异(RR 1.09,95%CI 0.99-1.20)。
- TFL对比无脉冲调制Ho:YAG的亚组无结石率更优(RR 1.11,95%CI 1.01-1.23)。
- 术后并发症复合率两组相当(RR 0.97,95%CI 0.66-1.43)。
- TFL的手术时间(SMD -1.19,95%CI -1.85至-0.52)、激光使用时间(SMD -1.67,95%CI -2.62至-0.72)和消融率(SMD 0.59,95%CI 0.15-1.03)均显著优于Ho:YAG。
- TFL对比无脉冲调制Ho:YAG的逆向推动程度显著更低(SMD -1.23,95%CI -1.74至-0.71);消融效率、总能量使用和住院时间两组相当。
关键数值与推荐
- GRADE评估证据确定性为极低。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 基于GRADE标准,证据确定性被判定为极低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare and assess the clinical outcomes between thulium fibre laser (TFL) and holmium: yttrium-aluminium-garnet (Ho:YAG) laser endoscopic lithotripsy of urolithiasis through a meta-analysis of comparative clinical studies. METHODS: A systematic literature search was performed in May 2022, grey literature search in July 2022. Comparative clinical studies were evaluated according to Cochrane recommendations. Assessed outcomes include the stone-free rate (SFR), complication rate, operative time (OT), laser utilisation time (LUT), ablation rate (stone volume/laser time), ablation efficiency (energy use/stone volume), total energy usage, degree of retropulsion, and hospital stay. Risk ratios (RRs) and standardised mean differences (SMDs) were extrapolated. Subgroup analyses, heterogeneity, publication bias, and Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) assessment were performed. International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) registration: CRD42022300788. RESULTS: A total of 15 studies with 1698 cases were included in this review. The outcome of SFR showed no significant between-group difference (RR 1.09, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.99-1.20). However, subgroup analysis of TFL vs Ho:YAG with no pulse modulation showed a SFR favouring TFL (RR 1.11, 95% CI 1.01-1.23). The composite postoperative complication rate was comparable between the two intervention groups (RR 0.97, 95% CI 0.66-1.43). OT, LUT and ablation rate were significantly better for TFL than Ho:YAG (SMD -1.19, 95% CI -1.85 to -0.52; SMD -1.67, 95% CI -2.62 to -0.72; SMD 0.59, 95% CI 0.15-1.03; respectively). The degree of retropulsion was significantly lower for TFL than Ho:YAG without pulse modulation (SMD -1.23, 95% CI -1.74 to -0.71). Ablation efficiency, total energy usage, and hospital stay were all comparable. Based on GRADE criteria, the evidence certainty was determined to be very low. CONCLUSION: Overall, there was no between-group difference for the SFR. However, compared to Ho:YAG with no pulse modulation, TFL rendered a better SFR. Shorter OT and LUT, a lesser degree of retropulsion, and a better ablation rate were noted in favour of the TFL. There was no overall between-group difference for composite postoperative complication rate, ablation efficiency, total energy usage, and hospital stay. Currently, the available clinical evidence was assessed to be of very low certainty.
引用
- Chua ME, Bobrowski A, Ahmad I, et al. Thulium fibre laser vs holmium: yttrium-aluminium-garnet laser lithotripsy for urolithiasis: meta-analysis of clinical studies. BJU Int. 2022. PMID: 36260370. doi:10.1111/bju.15921
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。