泌尿外科手术前患者理解程度的评估
研究采用回述法在泌尿外科手术前电话访谈中评估患者对风险、获益和替代方案的理解,99例患者中无人完全理解,73.7%为部分理解,识别风险平均仅12%,获益63%,替代方案35%;女性、既往接受过相同手术或一年内任何手术、以及门诊手术患者理解水平显著更高,回述访谈后90%患者对理解程度满意。
要点
- 泌尿外科手术前患者对风险、获益和替代方案的理解严重不完整,无人达到完全理解。
- 回述法电话访谈后,90%患者对自身理解程度表示满意。
- 女性、既往有相同手术或一年内手术史、门诊手术患者理解水平显著更高。
核心结论
- 在本队列中,患者理解程度严重不完整,术前访谈有实质性获益,研究结果凸显改善手术前患者教育的必要性,并提供基于回述法的电话访谈作为潜在解决方案。
研究设计与样本
- 采用术前电话访谈和回述法,纳入99例计划接受泌尿外科手术的患者,使用标准化风险、获益和替代方案列表对比患者回答进行评分,理解程度分为不完整(<25%)、部分(25-75%)和完全(>75%)。
主要发现
- 患者平均年龄64±10.9岁,46%为女性,32%说西班牙语;手术包括膀胱内肉毒毒素注射(24例)、中段尿道吊带(9例)、阴道闭合术(4例)、前列腺活检(24例)、输尿管镜(16例)、经尿道前列腺电切(11例)和经尿道膀胱肿瘤电切(11例)。
- 所有手术中,平均识别风险比例为12%,获益为63%,替代方案为35%;无患者达到完全理解,大多数为部分理解(73.7%)。
- 女性(P=0.02)、既往接受过相同手术(P<0.01)或一年内接受过任何手术(P=0.02)、以及接受门诊手术(P=0.03)的患者理解水平显著更高。
- 回述访谈后,大多数患者(90%)对自身理解程度表示满意。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为术前访谈有实质性获益,并提出基于回述法的电话访谈作为改善术前患者教育的潜在解决方案。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate patient understanding of risks, benefits, and alternatives (R/B/A) prior to urological procedures using the teachback method. METHODS: Using a preprocedural phone interview, patients recalled general knowledge and R/B/A of a scheduled procedure. A scoring system compared patient responses to a standardized R/B/A list to analyze the level of understanding, graded as incomplete (<25%), partial (25-75%), or complete (>75%). Following the interview, additional education was provided if understanding was inadequate, and patients were queried regarding their satisfaction. RESULTS: Patients (n = 99) comprised 46% women; 32% Spanish speaking; Mean age was 64 ± 10.9 years. Procedures included were: intravesical botulinum toxin injection (24), mid-urethral sling (9), colpocleisis (4), prostate biopsy (24), ureteroscopy (16), transurethral resection prostate (11), transurethral resection bladder tumor (11). Across all procedures, the average percent of risks identified was 12%, benefits 63%, and alternatives 35%. No patients had complete understanding, but most had partial (73.7%). Patients had significantly higher level of understanding if they were female (P = 0.02), underwent the same procedure previously (P < 0.01) or any surgery within a year (P = 0.02), and were undergoing an in-office procedures (P = 0.03). After the teachback interview, most patients (90%) were satisfied with their understanding. CONCLUSION: In our cohort, patient understanding was alarmingly incomplete and there was substantial benefit in pre-procedural interviews. Our findings highlight the need for improvement in patient education prior to surgery and offers a potential solution using a teachback-based telephone interview.
引用
- Schulz AE, Dave P, Clearwater W, et al. Assessment of Patient Understanding Prior to Urological Procedures. Urology. 2022. PMID: 36195166. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2022.09.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。