指南与共识泌尿系结石

柔性输尿管肾镜统一分级工具(TULIP-tool):关于柔性输尿管肾镜标准化评估的德尔菲共识项目

The Uniform grading tooL for flexIble ureterorenoscoPes (TULIP-tool): a Delphi consensus project on standardised evaluation of flexible ureterorenoscopes.
指南 / 共识 · BJU Int · 2022-10-26

本项目采用改良德尔菲技术分三阶段构建评估柔性输尿管肾镜(fURS)的标准化工具。由30名泌尿内镜专家参与,两轮问卷对6个主类别和12个亚类别的相关性与定义达成共识,后续三轮问卷对所有(亚)类别的测量方法达成共识,最终形成TULIP工具。

要点

  • TULIP工具通过改良德尔菲共识形成,用于标准化评估柔性输尿管肾镜。
  • 共识涵盖6个主类别和12个亚类别的相关性、定义及测量方法。
  • 该工具旨在促进未来柔性输尿管肾镜功能与操控性结果的比较。

核心结论

  • 改良德尔菲共识项目就评估柔性输尿管肾镜的标准化分级工具TULIP达成共识,为在该研究领域建立统一性以促进未来功能与操控性结果比较迈出第一步。

研究设计与样本

  • 在指导小组指导下采用基于改良德尔菲技术的三阶段共识构建方法。
  • 首先通过系统范围综述识别用于评估fURS的镜体相关和用户相关参数。
  • 然后定义主要类别和亚类别并选择专家小组。
  • 最后进行两步改良德尔菲共识项目:第一步就评估fURS所需的每个(亚)类别的相关性和准确定义达成共识,第二步就这些(亚)类别的评估方法(设置、所用工具和结果单位)达成共识。
  • 共识在预设的80%高一致性阈值下达成。

主要发现

  • 专家小组由30名泌尿内镜领域专家组成。
  • 改良德尔菲共识项目第一步包括两份问卷,两份问卷的应答率均为97%(n=29)。
  • 就6个主要类别和12个亚类别的相关性和定义达成共识。
  • 第二步包括三份问卷,应答率分别为90%、97%和100%。
  • 就所有(亚)类别的测量方法达成共识。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识阈值预设为80%高一致性。
  • 就6个主要类别和12个亚类别的相关性和定义达成共识。
  • 就所有(亚)类别的测量方法达成共识。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To develop a standardised tool to evaluate flexible ureterorenoscopes (fURS). MATERIALS AND METHODS: A three-stage consensus building approach based on the modified Delphi technique was performed under guidance of a steering group. First, scope- and user-related parameters used to evaluate fURS were identified through a systematic scoping review. Then, the main categories and subcategories were defined, and the expert panel was selected. Finally, a two-step modified Delphi consensus project was conducted to firstly obtain consensus on the relevance and exact definition of each (sub)category necessary to evaluate fURS, and secondly on the evaluation method (setting, used tools and unit of outcome) of those (sub)categories. Consensus was reached at a predefined threshold of 80% high agreement. RESULTS: The panel consisted of 30 experts in the field of endourology. The first step of the modified Delphi consensus project consisted of two questionnaires with a response rate of 97% (n = 29) for both. Consensus was reached for the relevance and definition of six main categories and 12 subcategories. The second step consisted of three questionnaires (response rate of 90%, 97% and 100%, respectively). Consensus was reached on the method of measurement for all (sub)categories. CONCLUSION: This modified Delphi consensus project reached consensus on a standardised grading tool for the evaluation of fURS - The Uniform grading tooL for flexIble ureterorenoscoPes (TULIP) tool. This is a first step in creating uniformity in this field of research to facilitate future comparison of outcomes of the functionality and handling of fURS.

来源:BJU Int,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Henderickx MMEL, Hendriks N, Baard J, et al. The Uniform grading tooL for flexIble ureterorenoscoPes (TULIP-tool): a Delphi consensus project on standardised evaluation of flexible ureterorenoscopes. BJU Int. 2022. PMID: 36208033. doi:10.1111/bju.15916

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。